首页|备案审查的鉴定式案例分析——以全国人大常委会法工委的备案审查工作报告为例

备案审查的鉴定式案例分析——以全国人大常委会法工委的备案审查工作报告为例

扫码查看
备案审查案例公开方式由零星反馈到报告披露再到公开出版的转变,为备案审查案例研究提供了丰富素材.然而,面对日益增多的备审案例,确定研究范式和分析体例成为备审案例研究的首要问题.备案审查制度建设和能力建设的完善,要求备案审查工作流程和方法的升级.基于此,文章选取涉及人口与计划生育规定类案例,探析备案审查鉴定式案例分析的流程和审查逻辑,进而确定该类案例以合政治性审查标准为主、合法性审查标准为辅的审查结构.与此同时,在鉴定式案例分析的普遍适用方面,通过案例佐证,明确备案审查鉴定式案例分析以"事项—权限—内容—特殊情形"为顺序的审查逻辑.
Appraisal Case Analysis of Record Review System in China—A Case Study of the Record Review Work Report to Commission for Legislative Affairs of the Standing Committee
The transformation of the disclosure method of record review cases from sporadic feedback to report disclosure and public publication provides rich materials for record review case studies.However,facing an increasing number of review cases,determining the research paradigm and analytical approach has become the primary issue in promoting review case studies.The improvement of the record review system and capacity building requires the upgrading of the record review work process and methods.Based on this,the paper selected cases involving population and family planning regulations,analyzed the process and review logic of the case analysis of the record review model,and then determined the review structure of such cases with political review standards as the main and legal review standards as the auxiliary.At the same time,in terms of the universal application of appraisal case analysis,cases are used to testify that the order of the review logic of appraisal case analysis of record review is"Event-Permission-Content-Special case".

record reviewappraisal case analysisreview criteriareview structure

祝海波、沈子华

展开 >

新疆财经大学,新疆乌鲁木齐 830012

备案审查 鉴定式案例分析 审查标准 审查结构

国家社会科学基金一般项目新疆财经大学校地合作招标课题新疆财经大学校级科研项目

20BFX0612023SLC010XJUFE2022D18

2024

新疆财经大学学报
新疆财经大学

新疆财经大学学报

CHSSCD
影响因子:0.527
ISSN:1671-9840
年,卷(期):2024.(1)
  • 24