首页|论过失犯的构成要件行为及其认定

论过失犯的构成要件行为及其认定

扫码查看
我国刑法通说观点将客观的不注意行为视作过失犯的构成要件行为,认为过失行为具备作为与不作为两个属性.这一观点违背了将危害结果作为过失犯必要组成的规范设置.应跳出存在论的思维方式,将注意义务违反行为视为创设一般法所不允许的风险的先行行为.结果避免义务与结果预见义务是由先行行为引发的刑事作为义务,二者并不等同于注意义务.行为人未履行结果避免义务的不作为才是过失犯的构成要件行为.应当采取合作为义务替代行为假设与例外的介入因素排除法分别检验过失犯的构成要件行为与结果.规范界定过失犯的构成要件行为有助于还原监督过失犯罪的规制内容.该类犯罪包含了故意不法与过失不法两个犯罪构成,规制了监督管理义务违反行为与未履行结果避免义务的不作为两个构成要件行为.
On the Behaviors of Consisting Elements of Negligent Offenses and Their Determination
The general view of criminal law in China regards objective inattention as a constituent act of negligence,and considers negligent acts to have the attributes of both action and inaction.This view is contrary to the normative setting of hazardous result as a necessary component of negligent wrongfulness.The breach of the duty of care should be regarded as an antecedent act that creates a risk not permitted by the general law,outside of the existential way of thinking.Duty of avoidance and duty of anticipation are criminal obligations of action triggered by the prior act,and they are not equivalent to the duty of care.It is the inaction of the perpetrator in failing to fulfil the obligation to avoid the result that constitutes the constitutive act of the negligent offence.The assumption of cooperation as a substitute for obligation and the exclusion of exceptional intervention factors should be adopted to separately test the constitutive elements and results of negligent offense.The way of thinking about defining the behavioral attributes of the constituent elements of negligent crimes can help restore the regulatory content of supervising negligent crimes.This type of crime includes two criminal components:intentional illegality and negligent illegality,regulating the violation of supervision and management obligations and the omission of failure to fulfill the obligation to avoid consequences.

negligent offenceomissionsduty of result avoidanceduty to cooperate as a substitute for the act hypothesissupervision of negligent crimes

韩子璇

展开 >

中国人民大学 刑事法律科学研究中心,北京 100872

过失犯 不作为 结果避免义务 合作为义务替代行为假设 监督过失犯罪

2024

西南政法大学学报
西南政法大学

西南政法大学学报

CHSSCD
影响因子:0.595
ISSN:1008-4355
年,卷(期):2024.26(6)