首页|数据权利界定、数据收集与个性化定价

数据权利界定、数据收集与个性化定价

扫码查看
数据产权可以被视为不可分割的一元权利,也可以将所有权和用益权分离,而数据所有权与用益权分离带来的经济意义仍有争议.数字企业提供基于数据的服务激励用户提供数据,同时利用数据进行个性化定价,并且导致用户遭受隐私损失.本文构建了一个垄断厂商模型,考虑了存在个性化定价与隐私损失时,数据收集者缺乏用益权与拥有用益权两种权利界定下的数据收集行为与福利影响.研究发现,数据收集者缺乏用益权时,隐私成本较高则不会有数据收集,隐私成本较低会出现过度的数据收集,体现为收集者耗费大量成本获取所有用户的数据.收集者拥有初始用益权,且用户拥有数据所有权时,反而可以实现有效率的数据收集,提高用户的剩余和社会福利.进一步分析收集者同时拥有数据所有权和用益权的情况,发现数据所有权只影响社会福利在数据收集者与用户之间的分配.因此,应当考虑数据所有权和用益权分离的权利界定架构,并且分场景讨论数据用益权归属:当隐私成本较低时,应赋予数据收集者用益权,并且让用户通过"删除权"等方式行使所有权,以提高社会福利和用户剩余;当隐私成本较高或用户会低估隐私成本时,应采取禁止数据收集而非确权的方式,以保护敏感数据.
Data ownership,data collection and personalized pricing
Data ownership can either be considered as an indivisible monistic right or sepa-rated into ownership and usufruct,but the economic significance of data ownership and usufruct separation remains controversial.Digital enterprises'data-based services incentivize users to provide data,but also result in loss of privacy for users through personalized pricing.This paper constructs a monopoly firm model to explore the impact of data collection behavior and welfare under the definition of lack of usufruct and possession of usufruct when there is personalized pricing and privacy loss.The study finds that without usufruct,data collection will not occur if the privacy cost is high,but excessive data collection will occur if the privacy cost is low.When the collector has the initial usufruct and the user has ownership of the data,efficient data collec-tion can be achieved,improving user surplus and social welfare.Data ownership only affects the distribution of social welfare between the collector and user.Therefore,we should consider the right definition framework of data ownership and usufruct separation and discuss the ownership of data usufruct in different scenarios.When the privacy cost is low,data collectors should be granted usufruct,and users should be allowed to exercise ownership through the"deletion right"and other ways to improve social welfare and user surplus.When the cost of privacy is high or users underestimate the cost of privacy,the method of prohibiting data collection should be adopted to protect sensitive data,rather than confirming rights.

data ownershipdata collectionpersonalized pricingprivacy cost

王泰茗、李三希、刘小鲁

展开 >

中国人民大学经济学院,北京 100872

中国人民大学数字经济研究中心,北京 100872

中国人民大学国有经济研究院,北京 100872

数据权利 数据收集 个性化定价 隐私成本

国家自然科学基金重大项目国家自然科学基金重大项目北京市自然科学基金重点项目教育部人文社会科学青年项目中国人民大学2023年度中央高校建设世界一流大学(学科)特色发展引导专项资金

7219280172192802Z22000120YJC790052

2024

系统工程理论与实践
中国系统工程学会

系统工程理论与实践

CSTPCDCSSCI北大核心
影响因子:1.575
ISSN:1000-6788
年,卷(期):2024.44(1)
  • 27