首页|法源思维及其方法论意义

法源思维及其方法论意义

扫码查看
严格适用制定法,可有效约束法官的审判活动,但也会出现教条主义和机械司法等问题.而允许法官在案件中随机融进价值和其他社会规范,则会消解制定法的权威.为维护制定法的权威,恰当地运用制定法,有必要引入法源思维.把法源理论转化为法源思维,对缓解制定法的刚性、融洽制定法与其他社会规范的关系、更好地化解纠纷具有重要的方法论意义.法源思维是对法源理论的方法论凝练,在开放制定法的基础上,重新理解、阐释和运用法律,在语境中构造依法办事之法.法源思维具有开放性,旨在更宽的法源形式中寻找裁判理由,在个案中重塑法律的意义.但需要综合运用法律方法以限缩无度扩张的价值入法、能动司法或执法.法源思维既尊重制定法的权威,又以法之名探寻语境中的法律意义,是捍卫法治的思维方法.
The Thinking of the Sources of Law and Its Methodological Significance
Strictly applying statutory laws can effectively constrain the judicial activities,but it may also lead to issues such as dogmatism and mechanical justice.Allowing judges to randomly incorporate values and other so-cial norms into cases,with broad discretion,will erode the authority of enacted laws.To maintain the authority of statutory laws and apply them appropriately,it is necessary to apply the thinking of the sources of law.Transforming the theory of the sources of law into the thinking of the sources of law has positive methodological significance in alleviating the rigidity of enacted laws,harmonizing the relationship between enacted laws and other social norms,and better resolving disputes.The thinking of the sources of law is a methodological refine-ment of legal source theory,which is a method of re-understanding,interpreting,and applying the law on the basis of open legislation and constructing a legal framework for handling affairs in accordance with the law in the context.The thinking of the sources of law has openness,aiming to find reasons for judgment in a wider range of legal forms and reshape the meaning of law in context.It also requires the comprehensive application of legal methods to limit the value of unlimited expansion into law,active judiciary,or law enforcement.The thinking of the sources of law not only respects the authority of formulating laws,but also explores the legal significance in the context under the name of law,which is a thinking method for defending the rule of law.

the Thinking of the Sources of Lawthe Thinking of Rule of lawLegal MethodsSystematic Thinkingthe Logic of Rule of Law

陈金钊、刘雷

展开 >

华东政法大学法律方法研究院

法源思维 法治思维 法律方法 体系思维 法治逻辑

教育部哲学社会科学研究重大课题

2022JZDZ003

2024

学习与探索
黑龙江省社会科学院

学习与探索

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.6
ISSN:1002-462X
年,卷(期):2024.(6)