Vertical Interlock and Firm Value:"Tunnel Effect"or"Supervision Effect"
Vertical interlock refers to the senior executives of a listed company who have served as senior execu-tives or had experience in senior management positions in controlling shareholder units.In existing literature,scholars have paid more attention to the impact of horizontal association behaviors of executives such as chain directors on companies,and have paid less attention to the common phenomenon of vertical association among executives in companies.Although at the policy level,the China Securities Regulatory Commission(CSRC)pro-posed the requirements of"three separations"and"five separations"in 1999 and 2001,strictly controlling the appointment of executives in controlling shareholder units at the same time,due to the lack of specific punish-ment measures,the actual impact is limited.Therefore,the vertical interlock still exists in Chinese listed compa-nies.In theory,on the one hand,controlling shareholders can alleviate the first type of agency conflict with man-agement through vertical interlock,fully exerting their"supervisory effect"on executives and having a positive impact on corporate value.On the other hand,vertical interlock stimulates controlling shareholders to exert a"tunnel effect",infringing on the interests of small and medium-sized shareholders and damaging the company's value.Based on this,whether the vertical interlock exacerbates the encroachment of major shareholders on mi-nority shareholders or enhances the supervision of management is an important issue in the direction of corporate governance.The article enriches the research results of vertical interlock and has important practical significance for improving the governance level of listed companies.This result also provides certain reference value for the introduction of a new governance mechanism of cumulative voting system and future dual equity by regulatory authorities in China.This article takes A-share listed companies in China's Shanghai and Shenzhen stock markets from 2004 to 2019 as samples,uses text analysis methods,and manually matches the resumes of executives published by CSMAR with the database of related companies to further calculate the proportion of vertical interlock in listed companies.Vertical interlock is further subdivided into direct and indirect associations,chairman vertical associ-ations and general manager vertical associations,and the economic consequences of executive vertical associa-tions are studied in depth.With Stata 15.0 software for analysis,this article uses a Two Way FE panel regression model that controls sectors and years,while eliminating endogeneity using the Heckman two-stage method and instrumental variable method.The research has found that there is a significant negative correlation between vertical interlock and corpo-rate value.The mechanism test results indicate that the vertical interlock increases the likelihood of related party transactions and fund occupation behavior in listed companies,producing a"tunnel effect"by intensifying the tunneling of major shareholders.The further research shows that the negative correlation between vertical inter-lock and corporate value is more pronounced in non-state-owned enterprises,enterprises with low levels of infor-mation disclosure,and enterprises with poor legal environments in their respective regions.Moreover,companies with direct vertical interlock and vertical chairman interlock often exhibit lower corporate value.
controlling shareholdervertical interlocktunnelfirm value
国家科技期刊平台
NSTL
万方数据
