首页|制度—事务脱嵌:基层协商民主困境的生成机理及其治理机制

制度—事务脱嵌:基层协商民主困境的生成机理及其治理机制

扫码查看
基层协商民主已基本实现良善之治,但亦面临着一些实践困境.基层协商民主的实践困境根源于"制度—事务脱嵌"."制度—事务脱嵌"理论指出,治理事务是影响基层协商民主制度的关键变量,制度脱嵌于治理事务会导致基层协商民主出现实践困境.基层治理事务至少包括3类事务,即自主决策事务、动员式执行事务、依规执行事务.但是,当前的基层协商民主制度仅仅适配于某一类或两类事务,无法全部嵌入3类事务.当基层协商民主制度与部分事务脱嵌时,基层协商民主制度在脱嵌性事务中难以发挥作用,各类主体会采取相应的策略加以应付.于是,基层协商民主在脱嵌性事务中出现基层干部变通式执行、人民群众政治冷漠、政治精英过度参与、治理效果相对欠佳的实践困境.为此,基层协商民主困境的治理机制需着力于克服"制度—事务脱嵌"问题,让基层协商民主的制度设计能够嵌入治理事务之中,朝着分类运转的制度设计方向发展.
The System Decoupled from Governance Affairs:The Formation Mechanism of the Dilemmas of the Community-level Deliberative Democracy and its Governance Mechanism
The community-level deliberative democracy has basically realized good governance,but it also faces some practical diffi-culties.The practical dilemma of the community-level deliberative democracy is rooted in the"system decoupled from governance af-fairs".According to the relevant decoupling theory,governance affairs are the key variables affecting the deliberative democratic system at the community-level level,and the institutional decoupling will lead to practical difficulties in the community-level deliberative democracy.The community-level governance affairs include at least three kinds of affairs,namely,autonomous decision-making af-fairs,mobilization-based implementation affairs and regulation-based implementation affairs.However,the current deliberative democratic system at the community-level level is only suitable for one or two kinds of such affairs,and cannot be fully embedded in the three kinds of governance affairs.When the deliberative democratic system at the community-level level is decoupled from some governance affairs,it is difficult for the deliberative democratic system at the community-level level to play a good role,and various subjects will adopt corresponding strategies.As a result,the community-level deliberative democracy faces such practical dilemmas as the flexible implementation by the community-level officials,the political indifference of the people,the excessive participation of the political elites,and the relatively poor governance effect.Thus,the governance mechanism for solving these dilemmas needs to focus on solving the problem of the"system decoupled from governance affairs"so that the institutional design of the community-level delibera-tive democracy can be embedded in the governance affairs,and develop towards the institutional design of classified operation.

community-level deliberative democracydeliberative democratic dilemmasdecouplinggovernance affairsdeliberative governance

韩玉祥、许珍珍

展开 >

西北农林科技大学人文社会发展学院,陕西咸阳 712100

基层协商民主 协商民主困境 脱嵌 治理事务 协商治理

国家社会科学基金青年项目

23CZZ035

2024

云南民族大学学报(哲学社会科学版)
云南民族大学

云南民族大学学报(哲学社会科学版)

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.68
ISSN:1672-867X
年,卷(期):2024.41(4)