首页|专利侵权合法来源抗辩实证研究——基于63件实务案例的考察

专利侵权合法来源抗辩实证研究——基于63件实务案例的考察

扫码查看
专利侵权诉讼中,合法来源抗辩常常作为销售者免除侵权赔偿责任的重要法定理由,但该抗辩在司法实践中并不经常得到法院的支持.本文通过对63件相关案例的实证分析,发现法院在该类案件中积累了一定的经验,但还存在证据认定标准不一、举证责任分配不明确的问题,针对合法来源抗辩法律适用中存在的问题,可从以下方便予以完善,包括对不同主体分配不同证明责任,对其证据的要求也应有所区别,以及追加第三人过程中需保障司法效率和当事人诉讼权利的平衡等,以期为今后的法律实务工作提供参考方向.
Empirical Study on Legal Sources Defense of Patent Infringement—Based on the Examination of 63 Practical Cases
In patent infringement litigation,the legal source defense is often used as an important legal reason for the seller to avoid the liability for infringement compensation,but it is not always supported by the court in judicial practice.Through the empirical analysis of 63 relevant cases,it is found that the court has accumulated certain experience in such cases,but there are still problems such as different standards for determining evidence and unclear distribution of burden of proof.In view of the problems existing in the application of legal source defense,the following aspects can be improved:different subjects should be assigned different burden of proof,the requirements for their evidence should be different,and the balance of the judicial efficiency and litigation rights of the parties should be guaranteed in the process of adding a third party,so as to provide a reference direction for future legal practice.

patent infringementlegal source defenseburden of proof

罗宗奎、张袁然、李明达

展开 >

中原工学院法学院/知识产权学院,郑州 450007

专利侵权 合法来源抗辩 举证责任

2024

中国发明与专利
知识产权出版社,中国发明协会

中国发明与专利

CSTPCD
影响因子:0.15
ISSN:1672-6081
年,卷(期):2024.21(7)