首页|跨越科层理性:理解基层治理的"再标准化"转向

跨越科层理性:理解基层治理的"再标准化"转向

扫码查看
作为现代国家治理的重要工具,标准化是政府体系有序运作和推进基层有效治理的规范支撑.面对动态多变的社会现实,由科层理性驱动的标准化实践往往陷于治理目标失准、治理效能不彰的困境,这引发了基层治理的"再标准化"转向.本文从科层制政府理性禀赋的视角出发,构建"治理转向—理性拓展—有效治理"的分析框架,以浙西杭垓镇再造村级工程项目操作规范的行动为例展开分析,以探究政府理性与"再标准化"的逻辑关联.研究发现:基层政府主导的"再标准化"不仅将标准化视为兼具工具理性和价值理性的统一体,还能够兼顾科层管理的要求和社会治理的需要,整合正式规范和惯习经验.以此为基础,"再标准化"通过开放的标准设计、柔性的标准执行和适时的标准修正,重塑了契合基层现实的标准规范.从价值意蕴的丰富到基层的实践,"再标准化"实则是韦伯意义上的科层理性和基层社会治理理性的衔接与融合,是政府应对复杂场景并追求有效治理的复合理性特质的呈现.基于这一拓展了的理性禀赋,或可重新诠释基层政府的理性及其自主行动的逻辑,丰富与拓展中国式现代化进程中的基层治理图景.
Cross-Bureaucratic Rationality:Understanding the"Re-standardization"Turn of Grassroots Governance
Standardization,as an important tool of modem state governance,is the normative support for the orderly operation of the government system and the promotion of effective grassroots governance.Facing the reality of the dynamic and changeable society,the standardization practice driven by bureaucratic rationality often face the difficulties of inaccurate governance objectives and ineffective governance,which triggers the"re-standardization"turn of grassroots governance.Based on the rational endowment of modem bureaucratic organizations,this paper constructs an analytical framework of"governance turning-rational expansion-effective governance",and takes the operation specification of the village-level reconstruction project in Hanggai Town,Zhejiang Province as a typical case to explore the logical relationship between government rationality and re-standardization.We finds that the"re-standardization"led by grassroots government not only regards standardization as a unity of both instrumental rationality and value rationality,but also takes into account the bureaucratic management requirements and social governance needs,and integrates formal norms and habitual experience.On this basis,through open standard design,flexible standard implementation and timely standard revision,re-standardization reshapes the standard specifications that adapt to the grassroots scene.From the enrichment of value connotation to the standardization practice,re-standardization is actually the connection and integration of the Weber's bureaucratic rationality and the grassroots social governance rationality,and it is the presentation of the complex rational characteristics of the government to deal with complex scenes and pursue effective governance.Based on this expanded rational endowment,it may reinterpret the rationality of grassroots governments and the logic of their independent actions,and enrich and expand the grassroots governance picture in the process of Chinese modernization.

Re-standardizationBureaucracyCompound RationalityGrassroots Governance

袁方成、王丹

展开 >

华中师范大学政治与国际关系学院

再标准化 科层制 复合理性 基层治理

国家社会科学基金一般项目

22BDJ114

2024

中国农村观察
中国社会科学院农村发展研究所

中国农村观察

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:1.538
ISSN:1006-4583
年,卷(期):2024.(3)
  • 1
  • 31