首页|碳中和目标下中国氢能产业发展的路径选择

碳中和目标下中国氢能产业发展的路径选择

扫码查看
氢能在中国构建新型能源体系和实现碳达峰、碳中和目标的进程中具有举足轻重的作用,对于难以完全电气化的钢铁、水泥、化工、航空、海运等行业的零碳转型尤为关键。氢能产业发展目前已被纳入国家战略,然而,由于制氢技术多种多样,各种制氢技术的经济成本和碳排放水平存在巨大差异,如何选择一条兼顾碳减排有效性和成本有效性的路径,仍需要深入研究。该研究构建了基于不同制氢技术的碳减排成本有效性分析框架,运用平准化成本、生命周期评估、学习曲线等方法,从不同时间维度对主要制氢技术的碳减排成本有效性进行了比较分析和评估,并针对关键参数设置不同情景(基准情景、温和政策情景和碳中和情景),分析了氢能产业发展不同路径的碳减排成本有效性,力图为制定、评估和修订国家或地方氢能产业发展战略提供一种兼顾制氢成本有效性和碳减排有效性的思路和分析框架。研究结果表明:①现阶段(2021—2023年),煤制氢的碳减排成本有效性最优,弃电+AE制氢次之。②近期(2024—2030年),弃电+AE制氢的碳减排成本有效性将逐步超过煤制氢,光伏+AE、风电+AE和水电+AE制氢的碳减排成本有效性虽逐步提升,但与煤制氢相比尚有较大差距。③中期(2031—2045年),光伏+AE、风电+AE的碳减排成本有效性加速提升,逐步接近煤制氢。④远期(2046—2060年),可再生能源制氢的碳减排成本有效性将全面超越化石能源制氢,绿氢将在氢能产业中占据主导地位。建议:参考碳减排成本有效性分析框架,完善氢能产业发展规划,合理布局氢能产业发展路线图和时间表;改进碳定价机制,通过增加用能单位的碳排放成本,增强绿氢的碳减排成本有效性和市场竞争力;加大利用弃风弃光电解水制氢的政策支持力度,促进风光资源充分利用与氢能产业发展的协同推进;短期内充分发挥灰氢的碳减排成本优势,理性有序地发展灰氢产业,并积极引导和支持灰氢产业应用减碳技术,加快灰氢向绿氢过渡进程。
Path selection for China's hydrogen industry development under the goal of carbon neutrality
Hydrogen energy plays a pivotal role in the transition to a new energy system and the achievement of the goal of carbon neu-trality in China,particularly for the zero-carbon transformation of industries such as steel,cement,chemical,aviation,and shipping,which are difficult to completely electrify.The development of the hydrogen energy industry has been incorporated into the national strategy.However,due to the variety of hydrogen production technologies,the economic costs and carbon emissions associated with these technologies vary significantly.Therefore,determining a path that takes into account the effectiveness of carbon emission reduc-tion and economic costs requires in-depth research.This study constructed an analytical framework for evaluating carbon emission re-duction cost efficiency based on different hydrogen production technologies.Methods such as levelized cost,life cycle assessment,and learning curve analysis were used to compare and evaluate the carbon emission reduction cost efficiency of major hydrogen production technologies from different time dimensions.Various scenarios were set for key parameters (baseline,moderate policy,and carbon neu-trality),and the carbon emission reduction cost efficiency of the hydrogen energy industry development strategy was analyzed.The study aims to provide insights and an analysis framework for the formulation,evaluation,and revision of hydrogen energy industry develop-ment strategies at national and local levels that take into account the cost effectiveness of hydrogen production and the effectiveness of carbon emission reduction.The results showed that:① At the current stage (2021—2023),the carbon emission reduction cost efficien-cy of hydrogen production from coal is the highest,followed by hydrogen production from power curtailment+AE.② In the near future (2024—2030),the cost efficiency of carbon emission reduction of hydrogen production from power curtailment+AE would gradually ex-ceed that of hydrogen production from coal.Although the cost efficiency of carbon emission reduction of hydrogen production from pho-tovoltaic+AE,wind power+AE,and hydropower+AE would gradually improve,there would remain a significant gap between them and hydrogen production from coal.③ In the medium term (2031—2045),the carbon emission reduction cost efficiency of photovoltaic+AE,and wind power+AE would substantially improve and gradually approach the efficiency of coal-derived hydrogen.④ In the long term (2046—2060),the carbon emission reduction cost efficiency of hydrogen production from renewable energy sources would compre-hensively surpass that of hydrogen production from fossil energy sources,with green hydrogen dominating the hydrogen energy industry.It is suggested to utilize the analytical framework for carbon emission reduction cost efficiency to improve the development plan of hy-drogen energy industry and outline a development roadmap and timetable;to enhance the carbon pricing mechanism,thereby improving the cost efficiency and market competitiveness of carbon emission reductions for green hydrogen by increasing the carbon emission costs for energy users;to boost policy support for utilizing curtailed wind and solar energy as well as water electrolysis for hydrogen pro-duction,promoting the full utilization of wind and solar resources and the development of hydrogen energy industry;and to leverage the carbon emission reduction cost efficiency advantages of gray hydrogen by rationally and systematically developing the gray hydrogen in-dustry in the short term,while actively guiding and supporting the gray hydrogen industry to adopt carbon reduction technology,thus ac-celerating the transition from gray hydrogen to green hydrogen.

carbon neutralityhydrogen industrycarbon reduction cost efficiencylife cycle assessment

陈洪波、杨来

展开 >

中国社会科学院大学应用经济学院,北京 102488

中国社会科学院生态文明研究所,北京 100710

碳中和 氢能产业 碳减排成本 生命周期评估

2024

中国人口·资源与环境
中国可持续发展研究会 山东省可持续发展中心 中国21世纪议程管理中心 山东师范大学

中国人口·资源与环境

CSTPCDCSSCI北大核心
影响因子:3.126
ISSN:1002-2104
年,卷(期):2024.34(10)