中国人民大学学报2024,Vol.38Issue(6) :156-164.

"相反者"与"居间者"——亚里士多德《论天》的元素证明及其理论意义

Contraries and Intermediates:Aristotle's Demonstration of the Number of Elements and Its Significance

张家昱
中国人民大学学报2024,Vol.38Issue(6) :156-164.

"相反者"与"居间者"——亚里士多德《论天》的元素证明及其理论意义

Contraries and Intermediates:Aristotle's Demonstration of the Number of Elements and Its Significance

张家昱1
扫码查看

作者信息

  • 1. 南开大学哲学院
  • 折叠

摘要

学界通常认为,亚里士多德在《论天》中虽然承认宇宙由土、水、气、火四种月下元素和一种月上元素构成,却没有给出月下元素何以有且只有四种的严格论证.事实上,这部著作包含一套关于元素种类的完整证明.亚里士多德首先基于对三种单纯运动的区分确定了三种单纯物的存在,进而依据其"相反者理论"和"精简原则"将三种元素中的重元素和轻元素分别进一步区分为两类,最终确定了构成整个宇宙的五种元素.重构《论天》中关于元素种类的证明,对于我们理解亚里士多德的元素理论,以及《论天》和《论生成与毁灭》的关系都大有裨益.

Abstract

It is widely accepted that although Aristotle acknowledges in De Caelo that the universe is composed of one celestial element and four terrestrial elements(earth,water,air,and fire),he does not provide a rigorous argument to explain why only these four elements exist.In fact,De Caelo includes a complete demonstration to differentiate the elements.Aristotle first distinguishes three simple motions to establish the existence of three simple bodies.Based on his theory of contra-ries and the principle of parsimony,each heavy or light simple body within these three bodies is can further be divided into two kinds,respectively.Ultimately,Aristotle finds that there are five ele-ments included in the entire universe.This reconstruction helps us to understand Aristotle's theory of elements and the relationship between De Caelo and De Generatione et Corruptione.

关键词

《论天》/元素/证明/相反者/居间者

Key words

De Caelo/Elements/Demonstration/Contraries/Intermediates

引用本文复制引用

出版年

2024
中国人民大学学报
中国人民大学

中国人民大学学报

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:1.887
ISSN:1000-5420
段落导航相关论文