首页|关于真实性概念及其在历史遗产实践中运用的七项建议

关于真实性概念及其在历史遗产实践中运用的七项建议

扫码查看
不同的文化以及相关社会和专业群体,对真实性(authenticity)概念的理解存在很大的差异.在历史遗产保护与修复领域,为了建立必要的共识和明确性,须在发展和运用这一概念的西方文化语境下回归其本义和历史.真实性概念根植于西方文化,本文追溯"authenticity"一词的希腊词源涵义及其在中世纪法律和宗教领域与权威性的内在关联,剖析文艺复兴理性主义影响下真实性寓意的世俗化转变以及文艺复兴之后该语义的变更和偏离,并列举实例阐释历史遗产保护实践中真实性概念的模糊性.在此基础上,提出纪念物(monument)和历史古迹(monument historique)两个概念混淆和同化所存在的问题,进而对真实性、历史、记忆等概念进行反思和批判性认识,阐明日本伊势神宫案例在历史遗产保护实践中的特殊性及其人类学价值,揭示未来遗产保护领域对活态记忆关注的紧迫性.
Seven Recommendations on the Concept of Authenticity and Its Application in the Practice of Historical Heritage
Different cultures and related social and professional groups have different understandings of the concept of au-thenticity in the field of conservation and restoration of historical heritage.Therefore,it is vital to return to the original meaning and history of the concept of authenticity against the background of Western culture in which it was developed and applied,thus establish-ing necessary consensus and clarity.This paper reviews and rethinks the meaning and application of"authenticity"from various perspectives,including its etymology in Greek,medieval religious laws,rational criticism in the Renaissance,and contemporary technological and social developments.Rooted in Western culture,the concept of authenticity was originally related to the authority of normative and pioneering literary theory in both the legal and religious fields.The implied meaning of authenticity was interpreted by rationalism in the Italian Renaissance,secularizing its concept and integrating it into the emerging fields of linguistics and histori-ography.Authenticity has developed its application value in the prevention of forgeries in the field of conservation and restoration of historical heritage.Linking the concept of authenticity to the"universal"values it promotes,the World Heritage Convention con-fuses and assimilates monument and monument historique.However,Japan plays a twofold exemplary role:the role of the monument against the background of a memorial tradition different from that of the West,and the role of the monument historique built accord-ing to Western standards.The anthropological function of historical heritage can only be saved if it is infused with the active memory of technological society.

historical heritageauthenticitymonumentmonument historiqueliving memory

弗朗索瓦丝·萧伊、彭亮、吴美萍

展开 >

巴黎大学 法国巴黎 75007

天津大学建筑学院 天津 300072

历史遗产 真实性 纪念物 历史古迹 活态记忆

2024

中国文化遗产

中国文化遗产

CHSSCD
ISSN:1672-7819
年,卷(期):2024.123(5)