《杨尚昆年谱》上卷若干人物与地名考订——兼论新版《毛泽东年谱》的修订
A Textual Examination on the Errors in Person and Place Names in The Chronicle of Yang Shangkun's Life(Vol.1)——Also on the Revision to the New Edition of The Chronicle of Mao Zedong's Life
刘思源1
作者信息
- 1. 中国社会科学院大学历史学院,北京房山 102488
- 折叠
摘要
通过查证相关文献,考查史事背景和当事人任职情况,查证地方志,可知《杨尚昆年谱》上卷中人物地名有若干不准确处.如在判定电报收发电人时,将张震误作当时已经牺牲的张元寿等;将周恩来误作刘少奇,萧望东误作萧克等;将朱德、彭德怀开会地点南丰沟误作牛沟,子长县王家坪误作延安解放军总部王家坪等.新版《毛泽东年谱》采纳学界众多研究成果.中共领袖人物年谱编写者应重视学界相关的研究成果,年谱的修订完善需要编写者和学界共同的努力.
Abstract
An extensive study of relevant literature,local chronicles and historical background and persons in-volved shows that there are numerous errors in person and place names in the first volume of The Chronicle of Yang Shangkun's Life.To name just a few,it confuses the senders and recipients of some telegraphs,mistaking Zhang Yuanshou(who was dead then)for Zhang Zhen;it mistakes Lui Shaoqi for Zhou Enlai,Xiao Ke for Xiao Wangdong;it confuses Nanfenggou,the place Zhu De and Peng Dehuai met with Niugou,and mistakes Wang Jiaping,the head-quarters of the People's Liberation Army in Yan'an for Wang Jiaping of Zichang County.The new edition of The Chronicle of Mao Zedong's Life adopts numerous research results from the academia.It is advisable that compilers of the chronicles for Party leadership should attach importance to the relevant research achievements,and the revi-sion and correction to them require the joint efforts from the compilers and academia.
关键词
杨尚昆年谱/考订/人物/地名/毛泽东年谱Key words
The Chronicle of Yang Shangkun's Life/examination and correction/character/place name/The Chronicle of Mao Zedong s Life引用本文复制引用
出版年
2024
NETL
NSTL
万方数据