首页|高等教育语境下对学生处分行为性质的澄清

高等教育语境下对学生处分行为性质的澄清

扫码查看
受特别权力关系理论影响,传统上我国高校按内部法律关系处理与学生间关系,学校对学生违反教育法律规范或校规、扰乱教育管理秩序的行为实施处分,而司法救济仅限于剥夺学生受教育权的处分,学生权利未能得到有效保障.经过对114份高校与学生教育行政争议与权利救济判例的分析,发现对该处分行为定性的模糊与认识的分歧导致了对学生权利救济的不利.本文以此问题为导向,在辨析学界观点的基础上,通过分析高校对学生处分行为的外部性特征,尝试澄清处分行为的性质,证成高校对学生违反教育行政法律规范或学校规则所实施的制裁行为是一种教育行政处罚行为.
Clarification of the Nature of Disciplinary Actions Against Students in the Context of Higher Education
Influenced by the Theory of Special Power Relations,traditionally,our universities have dealt with their relationships with students based on internal legal relationships.The schools impose disciplinary actions on students who violate educational laws and regulations or disrupt educational management order,with judicial reme-dies limited to the deprivation of a student's right to education,leaving students'rights inadequately protected.Through analysing 114 cases of educational administrative disputes and rightsremedies between universities and students,It is found that the ambiguity in characterizing these disciplinary actions and differences in understand-ing have resulted in disadvantages for students seeking remedies for their rights.This article,guided by this issue and based on an examination of academic perspectives,attempts to clarify the nature of disciplinary actions by an-alyzing the external characteristics of how universities discipline students.It aims to establish that the sanctions imposed by universities on students who violate educational administrative laws and school rules constitute a form of educational administrative punishment.

administrative disciplinary actiontheory of special power relationsinternal administrative ac-tionexternal administrative actionhigher education administrative punishment

陆秦

展开 >

上海财经大学法学院(上海 200433)

行政处分 特别权力关系理论 内部行政行为 外部行政行为 高校教育行政处罚

2024

中国远程教育
中央广播电视大学

中国远程教育

CSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:3.094
ISSN:1009-458X
年,卷(期):2024.44(3)
  • 26