首页|理性主义在戴维森哲学中的核心作用

理性主义在戴维森哲学中的核心作用

扫码查看
在语言哲学等领域,戴维森与奎因在一些问题上得出了看起来一致的结论.但是,在这些一致结论背后可能存在的哲学基础的不同,需要给予充分注意.应该看到,由于戴维森的基本哲学倾向是理性主义的,故他在考虑语言理解问题时,是从理性原则出发的.因此,用作自然语言语义模式的塔尔斯基式的真理论、看起来与奎因一致的整体论和善意原则等,都应该被理解为理性原则,而不是奎因意义上的经验认知的助发现原则.重要的是,戴维森哲学作为一种理性主义哲学,并不完全是传统意义上的,它强调交流者间共享的因果环境,强调外在对象作为语句和信念的内容,并把此种语言和认知的外在主义整合进理性主义的体系之中,从而避免了传统理性主义的一些困难.
The Central Role of Rationalism in Davidson's Philosophy
Within the domain of language philosophy and beyond,Davidson and Quine converge on seemingly identical conclusions regarding certain queries.Yet,the philosophical underpinnings di-verging beneath these consensual outcomes warrant meticulous attention.It emerges that Davidson's philosophical stance is fundamentally rooted in rationalism,guiding his inquiry into language compre-hension from a rationalist perspective.Thus,constructs such as the Tarskian truth theory as a semantic model for natural language,alongside notions seemingly in alignment with Quine—holism and the prin-ciple of charity—are to be interpreted through the lens of rational principles rather than as empirical heu-ristic principles in Quine's context.Importantly Davidson's philosophy,as a form of rationalism,is not entirely traditional.It emphasizes the shared causal environment among speakers,highlights exter-nal objects as the content of statements and beliefs,and integrates this externalism of language and cog-nition into the system of rationalism,thereby avoiding some of the difficulties of traditional rationalism.

semantic interpretationDavidsonQuinerationalism

叶闯

展开 >

山西大学哲学学院(太原 030006)

语义解释 戴维森 奎因 理性主义

国家社会科学基金重点项目

23AZX019

2024

浙江社会科学
浙江省社会科学界联合会

浙江社会科学

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.677
ISSN:1004-2253
年,卷(期):2024.(2)
  • 35