首页|承认理论与谱系学的相遇:论一个融合的批判方案

承认理论与谱系学的相遇:论一个融合的批判方案

扫码查看
现代哲学以来,德、法两国的批判传统引人注目,德国法兰克福学派秉持着"内在批判"的方法,法国则有以福柯为代表的哲学家用谱系学方法进行批判.时至今日,法兰克福学派的第三代学者霍耐特在两种传统的对话和交锋过程中,逐渐将谱系学方法吸纳进他的承认理论当中,这种结合为我们重塑或接续一种时代化的批判社会理论提供了新的视角.通过对承认理论和谱系学的考察,我们发现,两种理论都有各自的优势和不足,这为它们的融合提供了可能性与必要性的契机.重要的是,在谱系学的条件之下,承认理论对规范的考察呈现出"诊断—批判—解放"的特征和优势,这不仅增加了它对社会现象的解释力度,还释放了其批判性和解放潜力.
The Intersection of Recognition Theory and Genealogy:On an Integrated Critical Scheme
Since the beginning of modern philosophy,the critical traditions of Germany and France have been notable,with the Frankfurt School in Germany upholding the method of"immanent critique",and philosophers such as Foucault in France using the genealogical method of critique.Nowa-days,Honneth,who is the third generation scholar of Frankfurt School,has gradually incorporated ge-nealogical method into his theory of recognition in the process of dialogue and confrontation between the two traditions.This combination provides us with new perspectives for reshaping or continuing a contemporary critical social theory.Through the examination of recognition theory and genealogy,we find that both theories have their own strengths and weaknesses,which provides an opportunity for the possibility and necessity of their integration.Importantly,under the conditions of genealogy,recogni-tion theory's examination of norms presents the characteristics and advantages of"diagnosis-critique-emancipation",which not only broadens its explanatory strength of social phenomena,but also releases its critical and emancipatory potential.

genealogyrecognitionnormpower

李建华、徐勐

展开 >

武汉大学哲学学院(武汉 430072)

谱系学 承认 规范 权力

2024

浙江社会科学
浙江省社会科学界联合会

浙江社会科学

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.677
ISSN:1004-2253
年,卷(期):2024.(12)