A logical framework and network form of multi-subject collaborative governance in comprehensive land consolidation from an organizational relationship perspective
Collaborative governance by multiple subjects is an inevitable requirement to pro-mote high-quality development of comprehensive land consolidation in the context of rural revi-talization.It is also an effective path to integrate multiple resource elements,coordinate the ac-tions of multiple subjects,and improve governance efficiency.This article first constructs a log-ical framework for multi-subject collaborative governance of comprehensive land consolidation from the perspective of organizational relationships.Using G twon,J county,Hubei province as a case study,this research constructs a multi-subject collaborative governance network through social network analysis,covering command transmission,resource flow,and infor-mation communication.It then examines the network's structural features and employs expo-nential random graph models to explore the networks'underlying mechanisms,both internal and external.The results show that:(1)The density of the three networks in the comprehensive land consolidation in the case area is low,and a closely connected multi-subject collaborative governance system has not yet been formed.(2)The command delivery network and resource flow network have a typical"core-edge"structure and"small world"characteristics.There are command delivery clusters centered on county governments and town governments,and re-source flow clusters centered on construction enterprises.A large number of rural collectives and villagers are located on the edge of the network and do not play a major role.(3)The for-mation of the three networks is affected to varying degrees by endogenous mechanisms such as reciprocity,core-periphery effects,transitive closure effects,and connectivity effects,as well as exogenous mechanisms such as subject attributes and entrainment effects.Based on this,it is proposed that in order to improve the effectiveness of collaborative governance by multiple sub-jects in comprehensive land consolidation,the stabilizing role of core subjects should be strengthened,diversified participation channels should be built,and the endogenous motivation of rural collectives and villagers should be brought into play.
organizational relationshipcomprehensive land consolidationmulti-subject col-laborative governancesocial network analysisexponential random graph model