自然资源学报2024,Vol.39Issue(12) :2881-2896.DOI:10.31497/zrzyxb.20241209

规划堕距与规划悖论:一个理解国土空间规划的新视角

Planning lag and planning paradox:A new perspective of territorial spatial planning

谷玮 吴次芳 徐忠国 游和远 王梦婧
自然资源学报2024,Vol.39Issue(12) :2881-2896.DOI:10.31497/zrzyxb.20241209

规划堕距与规划悖论:一个理解国土空间规划的新视角

Planning lag and planning paradox:A new perspective of territorial spatial planning

谷玮 1吴次芳 2徐忠国 3游和远 4王梦婧5
扫码查看

作者信息

  • 1. 浙江大学公共管理学院,杭州 310058;浙江省自然资源厅服务中心(浙江省自然资源网上交易中心),杭州 310063
  • 2. 浙江大学公共管理学院,杭州 310058
  • 3. 宁波大学法学院,宁波 315211
  • 4. 浙江财经大学公共管理学院,杭州310018
  • 5. 浙大城市学院国土空间规划学院,杭州 310015
  • 折叠

摘要

国土空间规划是空间发展指南、可持续发展的空间蓝图,是各类开发保护建设活动的基本依据.在经济社会迅速变迁的时代背景下,亟需新的视角将国土空间规划作为一个动态系统进行认识.针对国土空间规划系统内部要素和子系统间变迁速率不一致的问题,提出规划堕距概念和理论认知框架.规划堕距是指规划应然状态与实然状态之间的不一致,根据规划主要环节可将其分解为上向规划堕距和下向规划堕距.规划的本体性悖论、整体性悖论和价值性悖论是产生规划堕距的主要内生因素,分别指规划的确定性与目标和环境的不确定性之间的矛盾、国土空间治理的整体性要求和现实中规划权力的分割性现实之间的不匹配,以及多主体间的价值目标张力.三种规划悖论在规划的不同环节发生作用,最终导致规划堕距的产生.基于对规划悖论的理解,以弥合因本体性悖论、整体性悖论和价值性悖论导致的规划堕距为切入点,提出调整规划边界、优化规划权力分配和平衡规划价值取向等规划实践路径.本文提出的规划堕距和规划悖论,能够为理解大变局背景下的国土空间规划提供新视角和新思路.

Abstract

Territorial spatial planning serves as a guide for national spatial development and a blueprint for sustainable development.It is the fundamental basis for development,protection,and construction activities in territorial spatial domain,playing a crucial role in spatial gover-nance.In the context of rapid socio-economic changes,there is an urgent need for new perspec-tives to recognize territorial spatial planning as a dynamic system.This article addresses the is-sue of inconsistent rates of change among internal elements and subsystems of the territorial spatial planning system by proposing the concept of"planning lag"and a theoretical cognitive framework.Planning lag refers to the inconsistency between"ought to be"and"actual to be".Furthermore,this article decomposes lag into upward planning lag and downward planning lag based on the main steps of territorial spatial planning.The emergence of planning lag can be un-derstood from the paradox of ontology,the paradox of wholeness,and the paradox of value in planning.The contradiction between the certainty of planning and the uncertainty of planning objectives as well as social development context,the mismatch between the holistic require-ments of territorial spatial governance and the fragmented distribution of planning power,and the value-goal tensions among multiple stakeholders are the main endogenous causes of plan-ning lag.These three planning paradoxes act at different steps of the entire planning,ultimately leading to planning lag.Based on the understanding of planning paradox,this article proposes optimization paths for improving territorial spatial planning to bridge the lag caused by the three paradoxes.Furthermore,this article proposes approaches such as adjusting planning boundaries,optimizing the distribution of planning authority,and balancing the value orienta-tions of planning to address the practical dimension.The concepts of planning lag and planning paradox introduced in this article provide a new idea and a new perspective for understanding territorial spatial planning in the context of significant changes.

关键词

国土空间规划/规划堕距/本体性悖论/整体性悖论/价值性悖论/堕距弥合

Key words

territorial spatial planning/planning lag/paradox of ontology/paradox of whole-ness/paradox of value/lag bridging

引用本文复制引用

出版年

2024
自然资源学报
中国自然资源学会 中国科学院地理科学与资源研究所

自然资源学报

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:2.073
ISSN:1000-3037
段落导航相关论文