首页|个人信息保护法与侵犯公民个人信息罪的衔接机制

个人信息保护法与侵犯公民个人信息罪的衔接机制

扫码查看
《个人信息保护法》是数字时代的前沿性法律,具有前置法、不完整领域法、不真正附属刑法的特征,与《刑法》中侵犯公民个人信息罪的规定存在时差.为了有效融通规范之间的衔接鸿沟,需要将《个人信息保护法》嵌入侵犯公民个人信息罪的出入罪适用流程.在入罪衔接机制上,将两法中的个人信息范围作统一理解,避免犯罪圈的扩张化;将前置法关于个人信息的类型划分和处理设置,作为解释侵犯公民个人信息罪构成要件的方向,以实现罪刑均衡和法律衔接.在出罪衔接机制上,《个人信息保护法》上的"同意"因法益阙如而阻却刑事违法,其余《个人信息保护法》上的正当化事由均因法益衡量原理阻却刑事违法,相应正当化事由可分别归入刑法教义学上的正当业务行为、紧急避险、法令行为,而合理处理已公开个人信息应成为数字时代独立的新型违法阻却事由,前述事由可在个人信息分类场景下为相关行为出罪.
The Personal Information Protection Law is a cutting-edge law in the digital age.It has the characteristics of pre-emptive law,incomplete field law,and no real subsidiary criminal law.There is a time lag with the provisions of the criminal law on the crime of infringing on citizens'personal informa-tion.In order to effectively bridge the gap between norms,it is necessary to embed the Personal Informa-tion Protection Law into the application process of the crime of infringement of citizens'personal informa-tion.In terms of the criminalization linkage mechanism,the scope of personal information in the two laws should be understood uniformly to avoid the expansion of the criminal circle;the classification and processing settings of personal information in the pre-position law should be used to explain the constitu-tive elements of the crime of infringement of citizens'personal information,direction to achieve balance between crimes and punishments and legal coherence.In terms of the connection mechanism between crimes,"consent"in the Personal Information Protection Law prevents criminal violations due to the lack of legal interests,and other legitimate reasons in the Personal Information Protection Law prevent crimi-nal violations due to the principle of weighing legal interests.The corresponding legitimate reasons can be classified into legitimate business behavior,emergency avoidance,and legal behavior in the criminal law doctrine,and the reasonable handling of disclosed personal information should become an independent new illegal obstacle in the digital era.The aforementioned reasons can decriminalize related behaviors in the context of personal information classification.

Personal Information Protection LawCrime of Infringing on the Personal Information of CitizensConsentLegal Interest Measurement

童云峰

展开 >

华东政法大学中国法治战略研究院

个人信息保护法 侵犯公民个人信息罪 同意 法益衡量

上海市哲学社会科学规划青年项目

2023EFX010

2024

中外法学
北京大学

中外法学

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:3.903
ISSN:1002-4875
年,卷(期):2024.36(2)
  • 52