首页|涉案人供述的证据准入:考量因素与系统反思

涉案人供述的证据准入:考量因素与系统反思

扫码查看
我国证据种类中犯罪嫌疑人、被告人供述仅指狭义上犯罪嫌疑人、被告人在接受讯问时向办案机关作出的认罪陈述.目前,我国在肯定书面讯问笔录证据准入的同时否定其他形式记录的供述,否定行政机关所获供述的证据准入,刑事初查阶段涉案人供述的证据准入尚未明确,立案前涉案人供述随意转化为书证、传来证人.这既导致与案件有关的涉案人供述无法进入诉讼,又让部分不可靠的涉案人供述进入诉讼,可能造成冤假错案.涉案人供述因为违反了 自身利益,具有较高可信性,一般具有证据准入资格,但其是否证据准入还应当受到其他因素的影响,比如供述环境对供述自愿性、明智性的保障,涉案人供述引入诉讼的必要性,能否满足质证的需要等.我国应当赋予同步录音录像作为供述的证据准入资格,否定行政机关以及初查所获供述的证据准入,对传来证人以来源查证、出庭义务为准入前提,涉案人供述证据种类转化仍应当适用供述证据规则.
Among the types of evidence in China,the confessions of criminal suspects and defendants only refer in a narrow sense to the confession statements made by criminal suspects and defendants to the case-handling agency when being interrogated.In the admission of written interrogation transcripts as ev-idence,the Chinese law denies the admission of confessions recorded in other forms,and denies the ad-mission of evidence of confessions obtained by administrative agencies.The admission of evidence of con-fessions of persons involved in the criminal preliminary investigation stage has not yet been clarified.The admission of evidence of confessions of persons involved before filing a case free to transform it into docu-mentary evidence and summon witnesses.This not only prevents the confessions of persons involved in the case from entering into litigation,but also allows some unreliable confessions of persons involved in the case to enter into litigation,which may lead to unjust,false,and wrongful convictions.Because the confession of the person involved in the case is against his own interests,it has high credibility and is gen-erally eligible for evidence admission.However,whether the confession of the person involved in the case is admitted as evidence should also be affected by other factors,such as the voluntariness and wisdom of the environment of the confession.The necessity of introducing litigation,whether it can meet the needs of cross-examination,etc.China should grant access to simultaneous audio and video recordings as evi-dence for confessions,deny access to evidence for administrative agencies and confessions obtained in pre-liminary investigations,and subject witnesses to source verification and the obligation to appear in court as access conditions.The confession of people involved in the case converted into other types of evidence should still be subject to the rules of confession evidence.

ConfessionEvidentiary QualificationsTypes of EvidenceHearsay Witnesses

谢小剑

展开 >

江西财经大学法学院

供述 证据准入 证据种类 传来证人

江西省双千计划哲学社会科学领军人才资助项目

JXSQ20232030087

2024

中外法学
北京大学

中外法学

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:3.903
ISSN:1002-4875
年,卷(期):2024.36(2)
  • 96