首页|逻辑学在法学中的应用及其难题以欧洲大陆法学的知识成长作为考察样本

逻辑学在法学中的应用及其难题以欧洲大陆法学的知识成长作为考察样本

扫码查看
在"希腊化时代",罗马法学家开始自觉地学习、引进古希腊(尤其是斯多葛学派的)辩证法(术),把罗马法学逐渐发展成为一种希腊化风格的专门学问,提出较为系统完整的法学理论.在12-15世纪,意大利"注释法学派"和"评注法学派"确立了意大利、乃至整个欧洲大陆法学教学与研究的传统,这两个学派的法学家采取当时流行的"经院主义辩证法(术)",奉行一种强调形式论辩的"论题学精神".近代法学受自然科学确立的知识范式以及自然法学说或理性法体系的影响,渴望完全被科学化或数学化,按照自然科学标准构想法律公理(逻辑)体系,企图实现"法律公理(逻辑)体系之梦".19世纪以来,法学受到学者们的反思和批评,并遭遇一些逻辑难题(难以判断法律语句内容的真假).对此,法学家和逻辑学家提出了不同的解答方案:比如,特奥多尔·菲韦格的"法律论题学"、沙伊姆·佩雷尔曼的"新修辞学"、斯蒂芬·图尔敏的"论证图式"和冯·赖特的"道义逻辑",等等.
During the Hellenistic period,Roman jurists began to consciously study and adopt ancient Greek dialectical methods,particularly those of the Stoics.This led to the gradual development of Roman jurisprudence into a Hellenistic-style specialized discipline,which formulated a more systematic and com-plete legal theory.In the 12th to 15th centuries,the Italian"Glossators"and"Commentators"estab-lished the traditions of legal teaching and research in Italy and throughout continental Europe.These scholars utilized the popular"scholastic dialectic"of the time.They generally adhered to a"thesis-antith-esis"approach that emphasized formal debate.Modern legal scholarship,influenced by the paradigm of knowledge established by natural sciences and natural law theories or rational legal systems,sought to a-chieve complete scientific or mathematical precision.This aspiration led to the development of legal axio-matics(logic),with the goal of realizing the"dream of a legal axiomatics(logic)system".Since the 19th century,legal scholarship has faced reflection,criticism,and some logical challenges,such as the diffi-culty in determining the truth or falsity of legal statements.In response,legal scholars and logicians have proposed various solutions.Examples include Theodor Viehweg's"Theory of Legal Topic",Chaïm Perelman's"New Rhetoric",Stephen Toulmin's"Argumentation Schemes",and von Wright's"Deontic Logic",among others.

TopicInventionItalian StyleGeometrical StyleConceptual Mathematics of Law

舒国滢

展开 >

中国政法大学法学院

论题学 开题术 意大利方式 几何学方式 法律的概念数学

2024

中外法学
北京大学

中外法学

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:3.903
ISSN:1002-4875
年,卷(期):2024.36(5)