Effects of tribulus terrestris saponins on interleukin-1β-induced chondrocyte apoptosis and inflammatory factor secretion
Objective:To observe the effects of tribulus terrestris saponins(TTS)on interleukin-1β(IL-1β)-induced chondrocyte apop-tosis and inflammatory cytokine secretion,and to explore its underlying mechanism.Methods:①The mouse chondrocytes(ATDC5 cells)were harvested and cultured in the Dulbecco's Modified Eagle's Medium(DMEM).After 24-hour culture,the ATDC5 cells were transfect-ed with pcDNA-circ_0045714,pcDNA,si-circ_0045714,and si-NC,respectively,by using transfection reagents.②The ATDC5 cells were inoculated onto the 96-well plates,with one group cultured in normal DMEM(normal group),one group in DMEM containing 10 ng/mL IL-1β(IL-1β group),and the rest in DMEM adding with10 ng/mL IL-1β and TTS with concentration of 25,50,100,200,and400 μg/mL,re-spectively.After 24-hour culture,the survival rate of chondrocytes in each group was calculated,based on which the concentration of TTS used in subsequent experiments was determined.③The ATDC5 cells were divided into control group,IL-1β group,IL-1β+low-dose TTS(L-TTS)group,IL-1β+medium-dose TTS(M-TTS)group,and IL-1β+high-dose TTS(H-TTS)group.The ATDC5 cells in control group were cultured in conventional DMEM,the ones in IL-1β group in DMEM with 10 ng/mL IL-1β,and the ones in the other 3 groups in DMEM adding with 10 ng/mL IL-1β and TTS with concentration of 50,100,and 200 μg/mL,respectively.The pcDNA-circ_0045714-and pcDNA-transfected ATDC5 cells were cultured with the same method as IL-1β group,and were labeled as IL-1β+pcDNA-circ_0045714 group and IL-1β+pcDNA group,respectively.The si-circ_0045714-and si-NC-transfected ATDC5 cells were cultured with the same meth-od as IL-1β+H-TTS group,and were labeled as IL-1β+H-TTS+si-circ_0045714 group and IL-1β+H-TTS+si-NC group,respectively.After 24-hour culture,the proliferation inhibition rate of the chondrocytes in each group was calculated.④The ATDC5 cells and the pcDNA-circ_0045714-,pcDNA-,si-circ_0045714-and si-NC-transfected ATDC5 cells were inoculated onto the 6-well plates.After 12-hour culture,the apoptosis rate of chondrocytes in each group was detected by using flow cytometry.⑤The culture medium of chondrocytes was collected from each group,and the levels of tumor necrosis factor-α(TNF-α)and interleukin 6(IL-6)in the supernatant were detected.⑥The total RNA was extracted from chondrocytes in each group for synthesizing the cDNA by reverse transcription,followed by amplification for calcu-lating the expression level of circ_0045714 in chondrocytes.Results:①The survival rate of chondrocytes was lower in IL-1β group com-pared to normal group(LSD-t =15.396,P =0.000),and lower compared with that of IL-1β+50 μg/mL TTS group,IL-1β+100 μg/mL TTS group,IL-1β+200 μg/mL TTS group and IL-1β+400 μg/mL TTS group(LSD-t =4.879,P =0.047;LSD-t =7.686,P =0.001;LSD-t =10.657,P =0.000;LSD-t =10.073,P =0.000);while the differences between IL-1β group and IL-1β+25 μg/mL TTS group,and between IL-1β+200 μg/mL TTS group and IL-1β+400 μg/mL TTS group were not statistically significant(LSD-t =1.555,P = 0.918;LSD-t =0.584,P =0.999).Therefore,the TTS with concentrations of 50,100 and200 μg/mL were selected for the further experi-ments and were labeled as L-TTS group,M-TTS group,and H-TTS group,respectively,based on the concentrations.②The proliferation inhi-bition rate,the apoptosis rate,and the levels of TNF-α and IL-6 in the chondrocytes were higher in IL-1β group compared with those of con-trol group,IL-1β+L-TTS group,IL-1β+M-TTS group,and IL-1β+H-TTS group(the proliferation inhibition rate:LSD-t =55.829,P = 0.000;LSD-t =8.879,P =0.001;LSD-t =20.507,P =0.000;LSD-t =30.315,P =0.000;the apoptosis rate:LSD-t =27.508,P =0.000;LSD-t =5.076,P =0.032;LSD-t =11.689,P =0.000;LSD-t =21.284,P =0.000;the level of TNF-α in the chondrocytes:LSD-t = 29.990,P =0.000;LSD-t =7.720,P =0.002;LSD-t =17.182,P =0.000;LSD-t =24.615,P =0.000;the level of IL-6 in the chondro-cytes:LSD-t =33.441,P =0.000;LSD-t =6.324,P =0.008;LSD-t =15.440,P =0.000;LSD-t =25.096,P =0.000),and they were higher in IL-1β+L-TTS group compared to IL-1β+M-TTS group and IL-1β+H-TTS group(the proliferation inhibition rate:LSD-t = 11.627,P =0.000;LSD-t =21.436,P =0.000;the apoptosis rate:LSD-t =6.613,P =0.006;LSD-t =16.209,P =0.000;the level of TNF-α in the chondrocytes:LSD-t =9.463,P =0.000;LSD-t =16.895,P =0.000;the level of IL-6 in the chondrocytes:LSD-t =9.117,P =0.001;LSD-t = 18.773,P = 0.000),furthermore,they were higher in IL-1β+M-TTS group compared to IL-1β+H-TTS group(LSD-t =9.808,P =0.000;LSD-t =9.595,P =0.000;LSD-t =7.432,P =0.003;LSD-t =9.656,P =0.000).③The expression level of circ_0045714 in the chondrocytes was lower in IL-1β group compared to control group,IL-1β+L-TTS group,IL-1β+M-TTS group,and IL-1β+H-TTS group(LSD-t =43.218,P =0.000;LSD-t =9.487,P =0.000;LSD-t =22.136,P =0.000;LSD-t =34.785,P =0.000),and was lower in IL-1β+L-TTS group compared to IL-1β+M-TTS group and IL-1β+H-TTS group(LSD-t =12.649,P =0.000;LSD-t = 25.298,P =0.000),moreover,it was lowly expressed in IL-1β+M-TTS group compared to IL-1β+H-TTS group(LSD-t =12.649,P = 0.000).④The expression level of circ_0045714 showed a significant difference in the chondrocytes transfected with pcDNA and pcDNA-circ_0045714(1.00±0.00,4.18±0.14,t =39.342,P =0.000),which indicated the chondrocytes with overexpression of circ_0045714 were successfully constructed.The difference in the expression level of circ_0045714 among the chondrocytes transfected with si-NC and si-circ_0045714 indicated the successful silencing of circ-0045714 in chondrocytes(1.00±0.00,0.28±0.04,t =31.177,P =0.000).⑤The IL-1β+pcDNA-circ_0045714 group showed lower proliferation inhibition rate,apoptosis rate,and TNF-α and IL-6 levels in the chondrocytes compared to IL-1β+pcDNA group(t =16.290,P =0.000;t =11.359,P =0.000;t =11.988,P =0.000;t =12.266,P = 0.000).⑥The IL-1β+H-TTS+si-circ_0045714 group exhibited higher proliferation inhibition rate,apoptosis rate,and TNF-α and IL-6 levels in the chondrocytes compared to IL-1β+H-TTS+si-NC group(t =9.586,P =0.001;t =9.120,P =0.001;t =7.069,P =0.002;t =10.548,P =0.001).Conclusion:The TTS can inhibit IL-1β-induced chondrocyte apoptosis and the expression of inflammatory cyto-kine,which has potential value in treatment of osteoarthritis.It may exert the effects by upregulating the expression of circ_0045714 in the chondrocytes,and the effects are stronger at the concentration of 200 μg/mL.