首页|污染环境罪的关键问题

污染环境罪的关键问题

扫码查看
行为违反国家规定属于污染环境罪的违法要素,对其认定应当按照法秩序统一性的逻辑进行,必须顾及前置法.行为人通过签订买卖合同等形式转移、处置危险物质的,可以认定为违反国家规定.对于本罪中排放、倾倒、处置等实行行为的判断,需要考虑刑法固有的违法性,且不能离开客观归责的法理.在行为人委托他人处置危险废物的场合,如果其不关心受托人的资质和实际经营情况,转移并任由受托人倾倒废物的,可以构成本罪共犯;但行为人因对方违约而拒绝将废物运回的,其犯罪故意可能被阻却.对"严重污染环境"的理解与本罪的保护法益有关,将生态学的人类中心论理解为生态学的法益与人类中心的法益不相抵触;认为本罪既可以是行为犯也可以是结果犯,既可以是抽象危险犯也可以是侵害犯的主张,未必具有合理性,且实益极其有限.对于"外环境"的确认要在本罪保护法益的指导下进行,避免出现保护不力的局面.对于实务中确定严重污染环境时不当运用鉴定方法,导致损害被放大的问题,也应给予充分关注.
On the Key Issues of the Crime of Environmental Pollution
That the behavior violates a state regulation is an element of illegality of the crime of environmental pollution,and such violation shall be determined according to the logic of the unity in legal order and by taking into account of predicate laws.If the offender transfers or disposes of dangerous substances by signing a sale contract or other means,the violation of a state regulation may be determined.For deciding perpetrating behaviors such as discharge,dumping or disposal in this crime,it is necessary to consider the inherent illegality in the criminal law,and unable to quit the legal principle of objective imputation.On the occasion where the actor entrusts others to dispose of the dangerous wastes,if the actor does not care about the qualifications and actual business situation of the entrusted person,and transfers and allows others to dump the wastes,he may constitute this crime;however,if the other party breaches the contract and refuses to return the wastes,the principle's criminal intention may be not established.The understanding of"serious environmental pollution"is related to the protection of the legal interests of this crime,and understanding the ecological anthropocentrism as the ecologically legal interests would not conflict with the legal interests of anthropocentrism,and the opinion that this crime may be either a behavior-based offense or a consequence-based offense,an abstract danger-based offense or a actual danger-based offense is unnecessarily reasonable and enjoys extremely limited benefits.The confirmation of the"external environment"should be carried out under the guidance of theory on the legal interests protected through legislation on this crime,so as to avoid the situation of unsatisfactory protection.In addition,full attention should also be paid to the improper application of appraisal methods in the process of determining serious environmental pollution,resulting in the damage being magnified.

Crime of Environmental PollutionPerpetrating BehaviorSerious Environmental PollutionEcological AnthropocentrismUnity in the Legal Order

周光权

展开 >

清华大学法学院,北京 100084

污染环境罪 实行行为 严重污染环境 生态学的人类中心论 法秩序统一性

2024

政治与法律
上海社会科学院法学研究所

政治与法律

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:1.545
ISSN:1005-9512
年,卷(期):2024.(1)
  • 1
  • 20