首页|网络著作权算法私人执法的异化及其矫正

网络著作权算法私人执法的异化及其矫正

扫码查看
经由算法赋能、私法制度提供合法性的网络著作权算法私人执法,借助公权力体系肆意扩张,正在架构新的社会关系和催生新的社会规范.算法的设计缺陷和法律规制的缺失使得网络著作权算法私人执法存在异化为私主体的利益实现工具的风险,可能造成对网络用户合法权益的侵犯,具体体现为侵蚀用户表达权利、挤压公众合理使用空间、剥夺用户经济利益等.权力与权利的平衡应成为矫正网络著作权算法私人执法异化的规制目标,循着公权力合理限制私权力、增益私权利对抗私权力的规制思路,通过立法建立限权与赋权的制度体系,具体应建立算法审查制度、基本权利保护责任制度以及算法问责制度,配置用户算法解释权和申诉权等,可激发最大制度性合力,实现多元主体的利益平衡.
Alienation of Online Private Algorithmic Enforcement of Copyright and Its Correction
The online private algorithmic enforcement of copyright,which is empowered by algorithm and endowed with legitimacy by private law,is experiencing wanton expansion with the help of the public power system and hastening new social norms and constructing new social relationships.Due to design defects of algorithms and the lack of legal regulation,the online private algorithmic enforcement of copyright has a risk of becoming a tool for private entities to pursue their interests,which may cause infringement upon the legitimate rights and interests of network users,which specifically includes eroding users'rights of expression,reducing the public's fair-use space and depriving users'economic benefits.It is advisable to take the balance between power and rights as the regulatory goal of correcting the alienation of the online private algorithmic enforcement of copyright,follow the regulatory train of thought that public power reasonably restricts private power,and private rights are enhanced to counter private power,establish a system of regimes on power limitation and empowerment through legislation,specifically the regime of algorithm review,the regime of responsibility for protecting basic rights and the regime of algorithm accountability,grant users the right to interpret algorithms and appeal,thus stimulating maximum institutional synergy and achieving a balance of interests among diverse stakeholders.

"Notice-Takedown"Private Algorithmic EnforcementAlienationImbalance of InterestsLegal Regulation

张海燕

展开 >

中南大学法学院,湖南长沙 410083

"通知—屏蔽" 算法私人执法 异化 利益失衡 法律规制

国家社会科学基金湖南省社会科学基金国家人权教育与培训基地(中南大学人权研究中心)重大项目

16BFX20523YBA003CSUHR22010101

2024

政治与法律
上海社会科学院法学研究所

政治与法律

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:1.545
ISSN:1005-9512
年,卷(期):2024.(5)
  • 78