首页|强制、同意与性别平等:强奸罪入罪模式及其改革

强制、同意与性别平等:强奸罪入罪模式及其改革

扫码查看
我国刑法规定的强奸罪确立了以"强制手段"为核心要素的规范结构,可概括为强制模式.在强制手段或被害人反抗不明显的情形中,行为人违反被害人意愿实施性行为却难以受到刑法的制裁,从而使个人性自主权的保护存在重大漏洞.强制不是强奸罪不法的核心,违背他人意志才是强奸罪的本质.以同意替代强制是强奸罪法律规范发展的必然趋势.强奸罪立法的主要任务是为个体之间的性互动确立一个相对客观的、符合社会规范和性别平等价值的沟通规则.根据性互动的沟通结构及其特点,结合性互动行为的实践和不同模式的适用效果,我国宜采取修正的否定同意模式,即一般情形下适用否定同意模式,对虽然具有同意能力但其认知能力和防卫能力存在减损的脆弱人群应适用积极同意模式.
Coercion,Consent and Gender Equality:Model of Criminalization of Rape and Its Reform
The criminal law of China stipulates the crime of rape in a normative structure with the core element of"coercive means"which can be summarized as the coercive model.In situations where the coercive means or victim's resistance is not obvious,it is difficult to punish the actor who carried out such sexual acts against the victim's will by the criminal law,thus existing a major loophole in the protection of individual's sexual autonomy.Being against the will of another rather than coercion is the essence of the crime of rape.It is an inevitable development trend of relevant legal norms to replace the coercion with consent.The main task of the legislation on the crime of the rape is to establish,for the sexual interaction between individuals,a communication rule which is a relatively objective,in line with social norms and gender equality orientation.According to the communication structure and characteristics of sexual interaction as well as the practices of sexual interaction behaviors and the effects of applying different models,it is advisable for China to adopt a modified mode of No Means No,that is,the No Means No Model should be applied in general circumstances,but the Affirmative Consent Model should be applied to vulnerable groups who have the capacity to consent but their cognitive capacity and defensive capacity are impaired.

the Crime of RapeCoercionConsentGender EqualityCommunication

向燕

展开 >

西南政法大学法学院,重庆 401120

强奸罪 强制 同意 性别平等 沟通

国家社会科学基金(2020)

20BFX098

2024

政治与法律
上海社会科学院法学研究所

政治与法律

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:1.545
ISSN:1005-9512
年,卷(期):2024.(6)
  • 52