首页|Comparison and evolution of transcranial versus endoscopic endonasal approaches for suprasellar Meningiomas: A systematic review

Comparison and evolution of transcranial versus endoscopic endonasal approaches for suprasellar Meningiomas: A systematic review

扫码查看
原文链接
  • NSTL
  • Elsevier
Background: Meningiomas of the tuberculum sellae (TS) and planum sphenoidale (PS) are challenging to treat surgically. Transcranial approaches (TCAs) were the mainstay before endoscopic endonasal approaches (EEA) were developed, however the efficacy and safety of EEA approaches relative to TCA approaches remains unclear. Methods: The authors conducted a PRISMA-compliant systematic review of existing literature detailing the outcomes of both approaches. PubMed, Embase, Cochrane Library, and Clinicaltrials.gov were searched. Studies were included if they analyzed TS and/or PS meningiomas, included >= 5 patients, and reported at least one outcome of interest. Results: Overall, 44 retrospective studies met inclusion criteria, the majority being from single centers, between 2004 and 2020. In studies directly comparing postoperative outcomes among TCA and EEA approaches, EEA had significantly higher odds of visual improvement (OR = 3.24, p = 0.0053) and significantly higher odds of CSF leak (OR = 3.71, p = 0.0098) relative to TCA. Further, there were no significant differences between visual worsening (p = 0.17), complications (p = 0.51), and GTR rates (p = 0.30) for the two approaches. Meta-analysis demonstrated no significant association between nasoseptal flap (NSF) use and postoperative outcomes among EEA patients. There was also no significant association between study publication year and postoperative EEA outcomes. Conclusion: The present study demonstrates that EEA offers a viable alternative to TCA in the treatment of suprasellar meningiomas. In particular, EEA shows promise for superior visual outcomes, though postoperative CSF leaks are an important consideration among patients undergoing this approach.

MeningiomaEndoscopic surgical proceduresMinimally invasive surgical proceduresSkull base neoplasmsCentral nervous system neoplasmsTUBERCULUM SELLAE MENINGIOMASSUPRAORBITAL KEYHOLE APPROACHSKULL-BASEPLANUM SPHENOIDALETRANSSPHENOIDAL APPROACHSURGICAL-MANAGEMENTPROGNOSTIC-FACTORSFOSSA MENINGIOMASLEARNING-CURVERESECTION

Jimenez, Adrian E.、Snyder, M. Harrison、Rabinovich, Emily P.、Malkawi, Dima、Chakravarti, Sachiv、Wei, Oren、Cheshire, Madeline、Price, M. L. S. Carrie、Khalafallah, Adham M.、Rowan, Nicholas R.、Mukherjee, Debraj

展开 >

Dept Neurosurg,Johns Hopkins Univ

Dept Neurosurg,Tufts Med Ctr

Sch Med,Univ Virginia

Albert S Cook Lib,Towson Univ

Dept Otolaryngol,Johns Hopkins Univ

展开 >

2022

10.1016/j.jocn.2022.03.029

Journal of clinical neuroscience

Journal of clinical neuroscience

SCI
ISSN：0967-5868
年,卷(期)：2022.99
  • 3
  • 77