首页|从代议到参与:参与式民主对代议制民主的超越

从代议到参与:参与式民主对代议制民主的超越

扫码查看
代议制民主一直被视为当代西方最理想的民主形式。20世纪60年代初期,西方社会存在着大规模的社会抗议、政治冷漠等现象,代议制民主的弊端逐渐暴露。参与式民主理论在否定代议制民主的某些理念的基础上,强调公民的直接参与,拓展了民主参与的形式和领域,进而超越了代议制民主。然而,参与式民主并未完全取代代议制民主的重要地位,并在20世纪80年代逐渐衰落。协商民主进一步发展了参与式民主理论,提高了民主参与的可行性,关注社会复杂性问题,从而对代议制民主构成了更强烈的挑战。同时,面临西方社会的民粹主义、政治极化问题,西方民主理论依旧无法提出有效的解决形式。这也表明西方国家的民主政治问题本质不在于形式,反而有其更为深入的政治、文化原因,仅在民主参与的形式上进行调整难以满足民主政治发展的要求。
From Representation to Participation:Participatory Democracy beyond Representative Democracy
Representative democracy has always been regarded as the most desirable form of de-mocracy in the contemporary West.In the early 1960s,the shortcomings of representative democracy were gradually exposed when there were massive social protests and political apathy in Western socie-ties.The theory of participatory democracy,based on the rejection of certain ideas of representative democracy,emphasising the direct participation of citizens,expanding the forms and areas of demo-cratic participation and thus going beyond representative democracy.However,participatory democracy did not completely replace the important position of representative democracy,and gradu-ally declined in the 1980s.Consultative democracy further develops the theory of participatory democ-racy,increasing the feasibility of democratic participation and focusing on issues of social complexity,thus posing a stronger challenge to representative democracy.At the same time,Western democratic theory is still unable to propose effective solutions to the problems of populism and political polarisati-on in Western societies.This also shows that the essence of the problems of democratic politics in Western countries does not lie in the form,but has its own deeper political and cultural reasons,and that it is difficult to meet the requirements of democratic political development by merely adjusting the form of democratic participation.

representative democracyparticipatory democracydirect participationconsultative democ-racy

李可心

展开 >

天津师范大学政治与行政学院,天津 300387

代议制民主 参与式民主 直接参与 协商民主

2024

宝鸡文理学院学报(社会科学版)
宝鸡文理学院

宝鸡文理学院学报(社会科学版)

CHSSCD
影响因子:0.168
ISSN:1008-4193
年,卷(期):2024.44(5)