首页|《残疾人保障法》的司法适用:样态、功能与进路——基于244份残疾人司法裁判文书为分析样本

《残疾人保障法》的司法适用:样态、功能与进路——基于244份残疾人司法裁判文书为分析样本

扫码查看
《残疾人保障法》既是我国残疾人权益保障的基本法,又是推动我国残疾人事业发展的保障法,更是落实宪法"残疾人权益保障"条款的部门法,对其司法适用的实证研究有助于准确认识该法在保障残疾人权益等方面的作用、局限及其完善进路.本文以244份法院援引《残疾人保障法》的裁判文书为样本进行实证分析,发现该法在彰显维护残疾人合法权益的国家立场、化解残疾人矛盾纠纷和纠正残疾人行政违法行为等方面发挥了重要作用.但也存在残疾人司法裁判文书说理简单、法律适用标准不统一和残疾人案件诉源治理效果不好等问题.宜细化《残疾人保障法》立法表达,完善残疾人保障的地方立法,创新残疾人民事公益诉讼的制度机制;定期发布残疾人相关司法解释和典型案例,强化残疾人裁判文书释法说理,提升残疾人案件诉源治理效能;深化残疾人无障碍司法环境建设,以《残疾人保障法》的良法善治推动新时代残疾人事业全面发展.
Judicial Application Forms,Function and Approaches of the Law of the People's Republic of China on the Protection of Persons with Disabilities:Using 244 Judicial Judgements for Sample Analysis
The Law of the People's Republic of China on the Protection of Persons with Disabilities(hereinafter referred to as LPRCPPD)is a basic law safeguarding the rights and interests of persons with disabilities,and a security law promoting the development of the cause of persons with disabilities,as well as a departmental law ensuring the implementation of the provisions on the protection of the rights and interests of persons with disabilities in the Constitution of the People's Republic of China in China.So empirical research on its judicial application helps to accurately understand the role,limitations,and improvement paths of the law in safeguarding the rights and interests of persons with disabilities.We conducted an empirical analysis of 244 judgments citing the LPRCPPD,and found that the law has played an important role in highlighting the national position of safeguarding the legitimate rights and interests of persons with disabilities,resolving conflicts and disputes related to persons with disabilities,and correcting administrative violations related to these persons.However,there are also problems such as simple reasoning and inconsistent legal application standards in such judicial judgments,and poor effectiveness in tracing and governing the cases involving persons with disabilities.It is advisable to do the following:refining the legislative expression of the LPRCPPD,improving the local legislation on the protection of persons with disabilities,and innovating the institutional mechanism of civil public interest litigation involving persons with disabilities;regularly releasing judicial interpretations and typical cases related to persons with disabilities,strengthening the interpretation and reasoning of judgments involving persons with disabilities,and improving the effectiveness of tracing and governance of cases involving persons with disabilities;deepening the construction of an accessible judicial environment for persons with disabilities,and promoting the comprehensive development of the cause of persons with disabilities in the new era through good governance using the LPRCPPD.

The law on the protection of persons with disabilitiesJudicial applicationReflection on the current situationImprovement path

王群、修君

展开 >

中共重庆市委党校 重庆 400041

残疾人保障法 司法适用 现状反思 完善路径

2024

残疾人研究
残疾人事业发展研究会

残疾人研究

CSSCICHSSCD
影响因子:0.615
ISSN:2095-0810
年,卷(期):2024.(2)