首页|中美APP儿童网络隐私保护比较研究——以监护人知情同意为视角

中美APP儿童网络隐私保护比较研究——以监护人知情同意为视角

扫码查看
在数字时代,各类APP中的儿童用户规模不断扩大,这加剧了儿童"触网"的低龄化趋势,而儿童本身的同意能力具有局限性,因此,监护人知情同意就成为保护儿童网络隐私的主要进路.世界各国也普遍重视儿童的隐私自决权保护,并将监护人知情同意作为儿童个人信息和隐私保护立法的基石,中美两国尤其将监护人知情同意作为APP儿童网络隐私保护的核心规则.监护人知情同意规则在实践适用中,可细分为儿童身份识别、监护人知情、监护人同意、隐私政策执行这四个实质性环节.通过对中美两国儿童常用APP的考察,审视监护人知情同意的实践过程,有助于分析我国的监护人知情同意规则在APP儿童隐私政策中的不足与成因."识别"环节的失灵、"知情"环节的受阻、"同意"环节的失效和"执行"环节的不透明等情形,在很大程度上造成我国APP中儿童网络隐私保护不力的困境.相对而言,美国的儿童网络隐私保护在诸多方面可资借鉴.立足于我国APP中儿童网络隐私保护的现实基础和实际需求,谨慎借鉴美国的有益经验,妥适调整我国监护人知情同意规则适用的各环节,可以有效提高该规则在儿童网络隐私保护领域的适用性.因此,拟建议设定"儿童身份识别"的法定义务、细化"显著清晰告知"的法定义务、实行"选择进入"模式的同意机制以及健全隐私政策执行的保障机制等具体举措,以实现全周期贯彻监护人知情同意规则的中国路径.
A study on the protection of children's online privacy between Chinese and American mobile apps:From the perspective of guardians'informed consent
In the digital age,the scale of children users in various apps is constantly expanding,which also exacerbates the younger age of children's"Internet access".In addition,due to the limitations of children's consent ability,in-formed consent by guardians has become the main way to protect children's online privacy.Countries around the world generally value the protection of children's right to privacy self-determination,and regard guardians'informed consent as the cornerstone of legislation on protecting children's personal information and privacy.China and the United States view guardians'informed consent as the core rule of protecting children's online privacy in apps.In practice,the appli-cation process of the guardians'informed consent rule can be divided into four substantive links:child identification,guardian knowledge,guardians'consent,and privacy policy implementation.The thesis takes apps commonly used by children in China and the United States as samples for investigation,examines the practical process of guardians'in-formed consent,and makes an analysis of the deficiencies and reasons of guardians'informed consent rule in children's privacy policy of Chinese apps.Situations such as the failure of the"identification"link,the obstruction of the"in-formed"link,the failure of the"consent"link,and the opacity of the"implementation"link have largely caused the di-lemma of inadequate protection of children's online privacy in Chinese apps.Relatively speaking,the protection of chil-dren's online privacy in the United States can be referenced in many aspects.Based on the realistic foundation and prac-tical needs of child online privacy protection in China's apps,cautiously drawing on the beneficial experience of the U-nited States and appropriately adjusting the various aspects of the application of the guardian informed consent rule in China can effectively improve the applicability of the rule in the field of child online privacy protection.Therefore,it is proposed to set up specific measures such as the legal obligation of"child identity recognition",refine the legal obliga-tion of"significant and clear notification",implement the consent mechanism of"selective access"mode,and improve the safeguard mechanism of privacy policy implementation,so as to achieve the Chinese path of implementing the guardi-ans'informed consent rule throughout the whole cycle.

children's online privacyright to privacy self-determinationguardians'informed consentidentification

陈飏、黄贵琼

展开 >

重庆邮电大学网络空间安全与信息法学院,重庆 400065

儿童网络隐私 隐私自决权 监护人知情同意 身份识别

重庆市高等教育教学改革新文科重点项目重庆市研究生教育教学改革研究项目重庆邮电大学网络社会发展问题研究中心重点项目

232069YJG2230842023SKJD10

2024

重庆邮电大学学报(社会科学版)
重庆邮电大学

重庆邮电大学学报(社会科学版)

CHSSCD
影响因子:0.719
ISSN:1673-8268
年,卷(期):2024.36(1)
  • 68