首页|约束战略缘何失败——以俄乌关系的演变为例

约束战略缘何失败——以俄乌关系的演变为例

扫码查看
联盟政治是重要的国际关系现象,约束战略是联盟政治的核心议题.那么,约束战略缘何成功或失败?一般而言,约束战略的成败在很大程度上受到约束国、目标国与对立国三方互动的影响.首先,处于约束国与对立国"拔河比赛"中心的 目标国始终存在背离与约束国联盟的动机,背离动机在转化成背离行为的过程中受到"趋利避害"原则的"过滤",趋利避害的过程外在地表现为 目标国威胁感知紧迫性与替代选择吸引力之间的动态博弈.然后,这一博弈互动过程又受到约束国与对立国的影响:约束国的约束策略与对立国的楔子策略分别通过调节目标国的威胁感知紧迫性与替代选择吸引力来塑造目标国的策略选择,从而决定约束国约束战略的结果.后冷战时期俄罗斯与乌克兰关系发展演变的四个不同阶段基本验证了上述分析框架的合理性与适用性:在第一个阶段,俄罗斯的约束战略获得了成功,而在后三个阶段皆以不同程度的失败告终,乌克兰危机的爆发、僵持与升级尤其构成俄罗斯约束战略失败的真实写照.
Why the Binding Strategy Failed—A Case Study from the Evolution of Russia-Ukraine Relations
Alliance politics is an important phenomenon of international relations,and Binding Strategy is the core issue of alliance politics.So,why do the binding strategies succeed or fail?Generally speaking,the success or failure of a binding strategy is largely affected by the tripartite interaction among the Binder,the Target and the Adversary.First of all,the Target at the center of the"tug-of-war"between the Binder and the Adversary always has the motivation to deviate from the alliance with the Binder.The deviation motivation is"filtered"by the principle of"seeking benefits and avoiding harm"in the process of transforming into deviation behavior,and the process of"seeking benefits and avoiding harm"is externalized as a dynamic game between the Target's perceived urgency of the threat and the attractiveness of alternative choices.Then,this game interaction process is influenced by the Binder and the Adversary:the Binder's binding tactics and the Adversary's wedge tactics shape the Target's strategic choices by regulating the Target's perceived urgency of the threat and the attractiveness of alternative choices,thereby determining the outcome of the binding strategy of the Binder.The four different stages of the evolution of Russia-Ukraine relations in the post-Cold War period have basically verified the rationality and applicability of the above analytical framework:in the first stage,Russia's binding strategy was successful,while the latter three stages all ended in varying degrees of failure.In particular,the outbreak,stalemate and escalation of the Ukraine crisis constituted a true portrayal of Russia's binding strategy failure.

Alliance PoliticsBinding StrategyWedge StrategyRussia-Ukraine RelationsUkraine Crisis

陈明霞、曾向红

展开 >

兰州大学政治与国际关系学院

兰州大学中亚研究所

联盟政治 约束战略 楔子战略 俄乌关系 乌克兰危机

国家社科基金重大研究专项2023年度兰州大学中央高校基本科研业务费专项资金重点研究基地项目

21VGQ0102023jbkyjd003

2024

当代亚太
中国社会科学院亚太与全球战略研究院,中国亚洲太平洋学会

当代亚太

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:1.685
ISSN:1007-161X
年,卷(期):2024.(1)
  • 88