大连理工大学学报(社会科学版)2024,Vol.45Issue(5) :73-82.DOI:10.19525/j.issn1008-407x.2024.05.008

平台经济背景下劳动关系认定路径探究——以劳动控制为视角

The Path of Labor Relations Identification under the Background of Platform Economy from the Perspective of Labor Control

苏泽儒 李二翔
大连理工大学学报(社会科学版)2024,Vol.45Issue(5) :73-82.DOI:10.19525/j.issn1008-407x.2024.05.008

平台经济背景下劳动关系认定路径探究——以劳动控制为视角

The Path of Labor Relations Identification under the Background of Platform Economy from the Perspective of Labor Control

苏泽儒 1李二翔2
扫码查看

作者信息

  • 1. 厦门大学知识产权研究院,福建厦门 361001
  • 2. 兰州大学法学院,甘肃兰州 730000
  • 折叠

摘要

平台经济的发展不可避免地伴随着平台与网约劳动者之间法律关系的认定.在司法实践中,二者是否构成劳动关系依然存在争议,其内在原因在于传统劳动关系认定模式的滞后性.在理论基础上,来源于他国的"准从属性劳动""独立劳动者"和"类员工"等解释路径依旧力有不逮.从劳动控制的视角出发,平台对网约劳动者的控制要素包括技术控制、法律控制和思想控制三者.在此基础上,平台主导的监控体系和私权力体系以及网约劳动者自发形成的主体性策略应成为认定平台经济劳动关系的事实构成.在判定平台经济劳动关系的具体路径上,一方面,应准确判定平台经济劳动关系的事实构成,并同"民事劳务""合作用工"以及"不完全符合确立劳动关系情形"等情况相区别;另一方面,应回归从属性,修正传统劳动关系认定模式,在回归从属性的基础上,应区分从属性的具体类型,并明确人格从属性、经济从属性和组织从属性三者在劳动关系中的权重高低.

Abstract

The development of the platform economy inevitably accompanies the recognition of legal relation-ships between platforms and gig workers.In judicial practice,there remains controversy over whether they con-stitute an employment relationship,primarily due to the outdated nature of traditional models for determining labor relations.Theoretical bases such as"quasi-employment,""independent contractors,"and"quasi-employ-ees"imported from other countries still lack sufficient force.From the perspective of labor control,platform control elements over gig workers include technological,legal,and ideological controls.Based on this founda-tion,the platform-dominant monitoring and proprietary systems,as well as the autonomous strategies formed by gig workers,should constitute the factual basis for determining platform economy labor relations.In deter-mining the specific paths of platform economy labor relations,it is necessary to accurately determine the factual basis of these relationships and distinguish them from situations such as"civil services","cooperative employ-ment",and"incomplete compliance with established labor relationship criteria".It is also essential to return to attributes and revise traditional models for determining labor relations.Regarding returning to attributes,spe-cific types of attributes should be distinguished,and the respective weights of personal attributes,economic at-tributes,and organizational attributes in labor relations should be clarified.

关键词

平台经济/劳动关系/劳动控制/从属性

Key words

Platform economy/Labor relations/Labor control/Subordination

引用本文复制引用

出版年

2024
大连理工大学学报(社会科学版)
大连理工大学

大连理工大学学报(社会科学版)

CSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.8
ISSN:1008-407X
段落导航相关论文