首页|循证教育的哲学批判与建构

循证教育的哲学批判与建构

扫码查看
循证教育理念正在逐渐深入教育各处脉络,对我国教育领域产生了多方面的影响.然而,循证教育理念是不完善的,这主要来源于其实证主义哲学本质所固有的理论困境.从教育本体论、认识论、方法论及伦理观四个维度探讨循证教育的局限性可以发现:在本体论维度,循证教育是一种还原性实践,忽视教育的生成性;在认识论维度,循证教育追求"研究—实践"的确定性,忽视教育中的不确定性;在方法论维度,循证教育的"方法—目的"是一种线性关联,忽视教育中的非线性关联;在伦理观维度,循证教育遵循实践的技术命令,忽视教育中的价值维度.从以上四个维度对循证教育进行的批判和厘清,为建构其实践原则提供了理论前提.因此,循证教育完善自身要基于以下原则:引入教育判断力,实现人的主体性回归;注重证据的价值判断,以达致教育问题的本质;厘清"目的—方法"的主客位置,重视"目的—方法"的内在关联性;构建复杂性和规范性相统一的方法论体系,对教育进行整体性把握.
Philosophical Criticism and Construction of Evidence-based Education
The concept of evidence-based education is gradually penetrating various aspects of education and has had a multifaceted impact on the field of education in China.However,the concept of evidence-based education is incomplete,mainly due to the theoretical dilemma inherent in its positivist philosophical essence.Therefore,the article explores the limitations of evidence-based education from four dimensions:educational ontology,epistemology,methodology,and ethics.In the ontological dimension,evidence-based education is a reductive practice that overlooks the generative nature of education.In the epistemological dimension,evidence-based education pursues the certainty of research practice and ignores the uncertainty in education.In the methodological dimension,the method purpose of evidence-based education is a linear correlation,neglecting the nonlinear correlation in education.In the ethical dimension,evidence-based education follows the technical command of practice and ignores the value dimension in education.Based on this,the article constructs the following practical principles of evidence-based education:firstly,it suggests introducing educational judgment to achieve the return of human subjectivity;secondly,it pays attention to the value judgment of evidence to reach the essence of educational issues;thirdly,we should clarify the subjective and objective positions of purpose method and attach importance to the internal correlation of purpose method;and fourthly,we should establish a methodology system that combines complexity and standardization to grasp education comprehensively.

evidence-based educationpositivismtechnical rationalityvalue rationalitypractice principles

徐乐乐、何美姣

展开 >

广西师范大学教育学部,桂林,541004

循证教育 实证主义 技术理性 价值理性 实践原则

广西高等学校千名中青年骨干教师培育计划人文社会科学类立项课题

2023QGRW005

2024

大学教育科学
湖南大学 中国机械工业教育协会

大学教育科学

CSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.772
ISSN:1672-0717
年,卷(期):2024.(1)
  • 36