首页|轻罪时代刑事立法泛刑化与重刑化之理性反思——以《刑法修正案(十二)》为视角

轻罪时代刑事立法泛刑化与重刑化之理性反思——以《刑法修正案(十二)》为视角

扫码查看
当下我国犯罪治理已进入轻罪时代,然而,十二部刑法修正案表明,轻罪时代我国刑事立法一直存在泛刑化与重刑化的趋势.以《刑法修正案(十二)》为例,泛刑化立法体现为扩大犯罪圈,重刑化立法体现为加重刑罚来惩治贿赂犯罪.从轻罪时代犯罪治理现代化要求以观,刑法应谨慎介入民营企业经营活动,相关法律已对民营企业内部背信行为设置较为完善的保护及救济措施,对之入罪会对民营企业正常经营造成较大影响,并违背现代公司治理的公司自治基本原则.加大刑罚力度难以实现贿赂犯罪预期治理效果,"行贿受贿一起查"不等于"行贿受贿同等罚",重刑化反而会导致贿赂双方订立攻守同盟,增加查处难度.加强对民营企业的保护与治理单位贿赂犯罪应从企业内部推动其依法合规经营,企业合规改革应该成为轻罪治理的首选方案.轻罪时代的犯罪治理不能延续传统泛刑化与重刑化的方式,刑事立法应谨慎进行犯罪化,刑罚配置应尽量轻缓化.
At present,China's criminal governance has entered the era of misdemeanors.However,the twelve Criminal Law amendments show that there has been a trend of generalized punishment and heavy punishment in our criminal legislation in the era of misdemeanors.Taking the Criminal Law Amendment(Ⅻ)as an example,the legislation of generalized punish-ment is reflected in expanding the criminal,and the legislation of heavy punishment is reflected in increasing punishment to punish the crime of bribery.From the perspective of the requirements of the modernization of criminal governance in the era of misdemeanors,criminal law should be carefully involved in the operation of private enterprises.Relevant laws have set relative-ly perfect protection and relief measures for the breach of trust within private enterprises,and the crime will have a greater im-pact on the normal operation of private enterprises and violate the basic principle of corporate autonomy in modern corporate governance.Increasing punishment is difficult to achieve the expected governance effect of the crime of bribery,"bribery was prosecuted together with taking bribes"is not equal to"bribery is subject to the same punishment as taking bribes",heavy punishment will cause two sides of bribery to form an alliance,which will increase the difficulty of investigation.To strengthen the protection of private enterprises and governance the crime of bribery in the unit,enterprises should be promoted to operate in accordance with the law,and the compliance reform should be the first choice of misdemeanor governance.The criminal governance in the era of misdemeanors cannot continue the traditional ways of generalized punishment and heavy punishment,criminal legislation should be carefully criminalized,and the penalty allocation should be as light as possible.

Misdemeanor GovernanceThe Criminal Law Amendment(Ⅻ)Generalized PunishmentHeavy Pun-ishmentPrivate EnterpriseThe Crime of Bribery

刘艳红

展开 >

中国政法大学刑事司法学院

轻罪治理 《刑法修正案(十二)》 泛刑化 重刑化 民营企业 贿赂犯罪

最高人民检察院检察理论研究项目最高人民法院司法研究重大课题

GJ2023B05ZGFYZDKT202309-01

2024

法学评论
武汉大学

法学评论

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:2.308
ISSN:1004-1303
年,卷(期):2024.42(2)
  • 47