首页|程序保障视角下证据调查请求权的理论构造

程序保障视角下证据调查请求权的理论构造

扫码查看
在当事人主义诉讼模式下,基于辩论主义的要求,提出证据是当事人的权限,即当事人拥有请求法院调查证据的权限.当事人对证据的选择是法院作出裁判的前提,法院调查的证据范围限于当事人提出申请的范围.法院的证据调查实施权受制于当事人的证据调查请求权.当事人通过证据申请的形式行使证据调查请求权,证据申请必须适式、适时.从当事人之间的关系来看,对方当事人有权对证据申请提出异议,可以提出证据抗辩.当事人的证据调查请求权应当依法受到保障,法院不得预断证据价值,不得基于对证据价值的消极预测拒绝对当事人提出的证据申请实施证据调查.当事人的证据请求权具有督促法院调查证据的效力.仅在证据申请不合法、证据调查没有必要以及证据调查存在难以预料的障碍时,法院才可以拒绝调查.
Under the litigant-oriented litigation model, it is the right of the litigant to present evidence based on the requirement of argumentation. The parties have the right to request the court to investigate evidence. The choice of evidence by the parties is the prerequisite for the court's decision.The scope of evidence investigated by the court is limited to the scope of the application made by the parties. The enforcement power of the court's evidence investigation is subject to the right of the par-ties to request evidence investigation. The parties exercise the right to request evidence investigation through the form of evidence application, and the evidence application must be proper and timely.From the perspective of the relationships between the parties involved, the opposing party has the right to raise objections to the evidence application and can raise evidence defenses. The right of the parties to request evidence investigation should be protected according to the law, and the court is prohibited from pre-judging the value of evidence and restricting or excluding the evidence applied by the parties. The right of the parties to request evidence investigation has the effect of urging the court to investigate the evidence. The court may refuse an investigation only if the evidence applica-tion is illegal, the evidence investigation is unnecessary, or there are irregular obstacles.

ArgumentationEvidence InvestigationApplication for EvidenceProhibition of Evidentiary PrejudgmentAdjudication of Evidence

胡骁

展开 >

西南政法大学比较民事诉讼法研究中心

辩论主义 证据调查 证据申请 证据预断禁止 证据裁定

重庆市教育委员会人文社会科学研究一般项目

23SKGH020

2024

法制与社会发展
吉林大学

法制与社会发展

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:2.707
ISSN:1006-6128
年,卷(期):2024.30(1)
  • 90