首页|刑事诉讼中的先行调查规则:基础规范与多元构造

刑事诉讼中的先行调查规则:基础规范与多元构造

扫码查看
先行调查规则是一项授权性规则,它赋予被告人在庭前或庭审过程中申请法庭排除非法证据、保障基本权利的请求权.当被告人根据《刑事诉讼法》第56条第1款申请排除供述、证人证言和被害人陈述时,法庭应当先行当庭调查取证合法性问题;对于物证、书证等其他证据收集的合法性,法庭可以先行当庭调查,也可以在法庭调查结束前一并调查.先行调查规则亦适用于回避、鉴真、认罪认罚的自愿性等重要程序性事项.我国应基于保障被告人权利和实现公正审判等价值和目标,逐步推进先行调查规则的多元化、类型化和体系化建构.在"一并调查"的构造下,程序性裁判仍具有重要意义,可以发挥对刑事诉讼主体的意识形塑和行为指引功能.先行调查的规范变迁表明,刑事诉讼改革需要一种联结庭前和庭审、一审和上诉审的结构性视角,需要颇具品质的比较法研究为立法者提供参考方案,更需要从实体、程序和主体的三维角度协力保障制度的良性运转.
The pre-trial investigation rule authorizes the defendant to request the court to ex-clude illegal evidence and protect basic rights before or during the trial.When the defendant files a motion to exclude confessions,witness testimony,and victim statements pursuant to Article 56(1)of China's Criminal Procedure Law,the court should investigate the legality of evidence before the tri-al;for the legality of physical evidence and documentary evidence,the court may conduct a collective investigation immediately or before concluding the investigation process.The pre-trial investigation rule also applies to important procedural matters such as avoidance,authentication,and the voluntar-iness of confession of guilt and punishment.Based on the values and goals of protecting the basic rights and achieving a fair trial,China should gradually promote the diversification,typification,and systematic construction of the pre-trial investigation rule.Under the structure of"collective investi-gation",the trial within trial still holds significant meaning,that is,being capable of shaping the consciousness and guiding the behavior of actors.The normative changes of the pre-trial investigation rule indicate that the reform of criminal justice requires a structural perspective that links pre-trial and trial stages,first-instance and appellate review,requires high-quality comparative studies to provide legislators with reference,and more importantly,requires a collaborative effort from the di-mensions of substance,procedure,and subject to ensure the healthy operation of the system.

Pre-trial Investigation RuleCollective InvestigationExclusionary Rules of Ille-gal EvidenceTrial Within Trial

牟绿叶

展开 >

浙江大学光华法学院

浙江大学立法研究院

先行调查规则 一并调查 非法证据排除规则 程序性裁判

中央高校基本科研业务费专项资金资助

2024

法制与社会发展
吉林大学

法制与社会发展

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:2.707
ISSN:1006-6128
年,卷(期):2024.30(4)
  • 15