"不理于人口":况周颐人际关系考论
"Treated With Negative Comments":Reevaluating Kuang Zhouyi's Interpersonal Relationships
杨柏岭 1郭增强2
作者信息
- 1. 安徽师范大学中国诗学研究中心
- 2. 安徽师范大学文学院
- 折叠
摘要
本文对学界有关况周颐人际关系的习见予以回应.况氏清醒地认识到自己"不理于人口"的人际关系,但或因生计之迫或因独葆清气而"不遑恤也".况氏与李详龃龉事属实,然李详悼念端方诗所讥讽者并非仅况氏一人,且二人交恶后绝非互不往来.况氏与郑文焯由交好到交恶,主要还是词学观点不同,而郑氏所谓"伧父"并非专指况氏.王国维是为数不多的对况氏气节称赞者,两人关系并非"一冷一热"所能概括,况氏同样对王国维有较为积极的反应.面对端木埰、许玉球、王鹏运及朱祖谋等,况氏既是聆听者,亦是对话者,更是宣讲者.
Abstract
This paper critically examines scholarly interpretations of Kuang Zhouyi's interpersonal relationships.While Kuang acknowledged that he was predisposed to be"treated with negative comments",he treated them"with a pinch of salt",possibly influenced by socioeconomic pressures or his adherence to purity of spirit.Although the disagreements with Li Xiang were genuine,Kuang was not the only person who was ridiculed in the poem Li composed in the memory of Duanfang,not to mention the fact that both still maintained a degree of contact after the enmity.Discord with his former friend,Zheng Wenzhuo stemmed primarily from differing lexicographic perspectives,and Zheng's portrayal of Kuang as a"boor"was not exclusively directed at him.On a different note,Wang Guowei was one of the few who praised Kuang,but they certainly did not make a"cold-friendly"partnership,because Kuang returned Wang with positive feedback as well.Additionally,Kuang actively engaged with figures like Duanmu Cai,Xu Yucheng,Wang Pengyun,and Zhu Zumou,participating as an interlocutor and even an instructor,assuming roles beyond a mere listener.
关键词
况周颐/人际关系/性格/词学观Key words
Kuang Zhouyi/interpersonal relationships/character/lexicographic perspectives引用本文复制引用
基金项目
安徽省省属公办普通本科高等学校领军骨干人才项目(皖教秘人[2017]161号)
出版年
2024
NETL
NSTL
万方数据