首页|三权分置逻辑与承包地、宅基地权利组辨析——基于超越二元论视角的三元组解构

三权分置逻辑与承包地、宅基地权利组辨析——基于超越二元论视角的三元组解构

扫码查看
为解决农地"三权分置"存在的逻辑适用和权利性质分歧,以黑格尔后的辩证法,一种哲学范式三元组,解构"三权分置",提出"可以三元组解构'三权分置'"命题.通过命题阐释得出,归属与利用构成农地产权关系根本矛盾,身份性与非身份性和阶层性与平等性为主要矛盾.以命题证成为主线,基于矛盾关系和特性认识,以内部证成和他者逻辑证成为线索,结合事实处分和法律处分之区分,提出并证立命题和"三权分置"法律逻辑.在证成中辨析二权分离与"三权分置",基于"三权分置"法律逻辑明确承包地"三权分置"权利性质,二权分离下经营权应为债权性使用权,"三权分置"下经营权应为物权性使用权.以"三权分置"法律逻辑应用于宅基地,明晰资格权应为宅基地使用权,使用权应为次级物权性使用权.
The Logic of Three Rights Separation and Identification of the Rights Group of Contracted Land and Homestead:Triplet Deconstruction from the Perspective That Transcends Dualism
In order to resolve the differences in the logical applicability and the nature of rights in the"Three Rights Separation"of rural land,based on the post-Hegelian dialectic,a philosophical paradigm triplet,this paper deconstructs this concept and puts forward the proposition that"the Three Rights Sepa-ration'can be deconstructed using a triplet".Through the interpretation of this proposition,the paper con-cluded that ownership and use constitute the fundamental contradiction of rural land property rights,while identity and non-identity,hierarchy and equality are the main contradictions.The paper took the propo-sitional justification as the main line based on the understanding of contradictory relationships and their characteristics,and took the internal justification and the logical justification of the Others as clues.It put forward and justified the proposition and the legal logic of"Three Rights Separation".Based on the legal logic of"Three Rights Separation",the nature of the separation of three rights of the contracted land is clarified.The management right under the separation of the two rights should be a creditor's right to use,and the management right under the"Three Rights Separation"should be the right to use in rem.The le-gal logic of this Separation is applied to homesteads,and it is clarified that the qualification right should be the right to use the homestead,and the right to use should be the secondary property right to use.

tripletthe logic of "Three Rights Separation"contracted landhomestead

陈浩林

展开 >

安徽财经大学法学院,安徽蚌埠 233030

三元组 三权分置逻辑 承包地 宅基地

2024

河北农业大学学报(社会科学版)

河北农业大学学报(社会科学版)

ISSN:
年,卷(期):2024.26(3)
  • 38