首页|补帑与惩贪的双重局限:清代"完赃减等"例的变化与施行

补帑与惩贪的双重局限:清代"完赃减等"例的变化与施行

扫码查看
"完赃减等"为清代律例体系独有.在审理挪移仓库钱粮、监守自盗以及贿赂案件中,"完赃减等"因案件的差异而具体表现出不同的样态.清代财政亏空严重,在财政税收及国家管理体制不变的情况下,要做到既严厉惩贪又能够完赃补帑并不现实."完赃减等"例弹性较大,在施行中形成了复杂的利益博弈局面,犯赃官员、承追官员、承审官员、连带者的最终结局都无法准确预测.虽然某些个案既做到了完赃又惩治了腐败,但从整体看,完赃和惩贪均未达到预期目的.因微观制度缺陷催生的腐败,必须在考量国家整体政治制度的前提下,对双方进行调整和改变,才能发挥二者的功效,否则腐败的制度根源便很难破除.
The Dual Limitations of Replenishing Treasury Funds and Punishing Corruption:The Change and Implementation of the Statute of"Completing the Loot and Reducing the Penalty"in the Qing Dynasty
The statute of"completing the loot and reducing the penalty"is unique to the legal system of the Qing Dynasty.In the trial of embezzling warehouse money and grain,internal robbery and bribery cases,due to the divergent content,the statute of"completing the loot and reducing the penalty"shows different kind of judicial patterns.In Qing Dynasty,the local fiscal deficit was serious,and it was not realistic to punish cor-ruption strictly and replenish treasury funds when the fiscal taxation and national management system remained unchanged.The statute of"completing the loot and reducing the penalty"is relatively flexible.In the game field created by the statute of"completing the loot and reducing the penalty",the final outcome of the officials who commit the stolen goods,the officials who pursue the case,the officials who accept the trial,and the associat-ed parties can not be accurately predicted,and the resulting outcome is that neither the complete stolen goods nor the punishment of corruption can achieve stable results.Although in some cases corruption was punished as well as stolen goods recovering,but from the perspective of the country as a whole,both have failed to achieve the intended purpose.The corruption caused by micro-system defects must be adjusted and changed on the premise of considering the overall political system of the country in order to give full play to the efficacy of both,otherwise the institutional root of corruption will be difficult to eradicate.

the statute of"completing the loot and reducing the penalty"replenishing treasury fundspunishing corruption

刘志勇

展开 >

浙江师范大学 法学院,浙江 金华 321004

完赃减等 补帑 惩贪

2024

哈尔滨工业大学学报(社会科学版)
哈尔滨工业大学

哈尔滨工业大学学报(社会科学版)

CHSSCD
影响因子:0.736
ISSN:1009-1971
年,卷(期):2024.26(6)