首页|能力分班有利于学与教吗——基于PISA2018阅读领域的证据

能力分班有利于学与教吗——基于PISA2018阅读领域的证据

扫码查看
我国中学普遍实施能力分班教学,但是,不管是研究领域还是实践领域,对能力分班的政策效果皆未形成一致性看法.基于PISA2018 我国四省市数据,综合利用两水平线性回归模型和分位数回归模型,评估学校能力分班对于阅读学科的教与学的效用、公平性以及作用机制后发现,对于学生阅读素养表现而言,不管是分班分层的重点班政策,还是学科分层的分层走班制,皆不利于学校整体成绩提升,而且存在固化或扩大学生间成绩差距的潜在风险.从作用机制上看,学校划分重点班并不能自然促进阅读学科教师教学改善,进而提升学生阅读素养成绩;而分层走班制则为阅读学科教师创设了教学有效性发挥的有利环境,对教学效果产生一定的正向调节效应.
Does Between-Class Grouping Benefit Teaching and Learning?—Evidence from PISA2018 in the Reading Domain
In the realm of both research and practical application,there remains a lack of consensus regarding the efficacy of be-tween-class grouping policies in Chinese secondary schools.Utilizing data from the PISA2018 study across four Chinese provinces and municipalities,a comprehensive analysis employing both multilevel linear regression models and quantile regression models was conduc-ted to assess the impact,equity,and underlying mechanisms of school-based between-class grouping on the teaching and learning out-comes in the field of reading.The findings suggest that,concerning students'reading proficiency,both the emphasis on between-class grouping and the subject-based grouping do not contribute positively to overall academic performance enhancement within schools.More-over,these approaches potentially exacerbate or perpetuate disparities in academic achievement among students.Regarding the mecha-nisms at play,the establishment of key classes within schools does not inherently foster improvements in the teaching practices of read-ing subject instructors,thus failing to elevate students'reading proficiency.Conversely,the subject-based grouping provides a conducive environment for reading subject educators to enhance instructional effectiveness,thereby exerting a positive moderating influence on teaching outcomes.

between-class groupingkey classsubject-based groupingPISApolicy impact

钱阿剑、赵茜

展开 >

广西师范大学 教育学部,广西 桂林 541004

北京师范大学 中国基础教育质量监测协同创新中心,北京 100875

能力分班 重点班 分层走班 PISA 政策效果

2024

湖南师范大学教育科学学报
湖南师范大学

湖南师范大学教育科学学报

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.945
ISSN:1671-6124
年,卷(期):2024.23(4)
  • 11