首页|新时代司法改革现代性与治理性之间的矛盾与平衡

新时代司法改革现代性与治理性之间的矛盾与平衡

扫码查看
中国自20世纪末开始的多轮司法改革具有现代性和治理性的双重特征,承载了民众向度与国家向度的双重表达.司法改革中这种民众向度与国家向度的不同表达,会在更深层次上导致来自司法改革现代性特征与治理性需求在结构、价值和效率等层面的错位,表现为权力架构与地方环境对司法改革的制约、实质法范式对形式正义与规则理性的消解以及司法改革背景下的"人案矛盾".走出司法改革困境的长久之计,是在国家治理性与社会现代性之间的社会辩证运动过程中,提出维持司法改革现代性—治理性结构动态平衡的共识性原则.
The Contradiction and Balance between Modernity and Governance in Judicial Reform in the New Era
The multiple rounds of judicial reforms in China since the end of the last century have dual characteristics of modernity and governance,carrying the dual expression of the dimensions of the people and the state.The different expressions of the dimensions between the public and the state in judicial reform can lead to a deeper mismatch between the modern charac-teristics and governance needs of judicial reform in terms of structure,value,and efficiency.This is manifested in the con-straints of power structure and local environment on judicial reform,the dissolution of formal justice and rule rationality by substantive law paradigms,and the"human case contradiction"in the context of judicial reform.The long-term solution to o-vercome the dilemma of judicial reform is to propose the consensus principle of maintaining the dynamic balance between the modernity governance structure of judicial reform in the process of social dialectical movement between national governance and social modernity.

judicial reformmodernitygovernancecontradictions and conflictsgovernance scheme

张式泽

展开 >

北京师范大学法学院,北京 100875

司法改革 现代性 治理性 矛盾冲突 治理方案

国家社会科学基金项目

17BFX182

2024

河南师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版)
河南师范大学

河南师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版)

CSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.475
ISSN:1000-2359
年,卷(期):2024.51(3)