首页|探寻现代中国的文明基础:康有为的文明论述与东西文化论战的开端

探寻现代中国的文明基础:康有为的文明论述与东西文化论战的开端

扫码查看
康有为在 20 世纪初较早地通过区分文明的物质层面与道德层面,发展出中国文明与西方文明各擅胜场的论述,下启东西文化论战."一战"爆发呈现的欧洲文明危机与袁世凯复辟呈现的民国初期的共和危机,激起了两种截然相反的主张,陈独秀持东西方文明不可调和论及"全盘西化论",反对辜鸿铭以中国文明拯救欧洲文明的主张,形成针锋相对的格局,清晰显示现代中国建构的文明基础问题,已经与王朝时代的夷夏之辨很不一样.更多论者主张东西方文明调和论,李大钊、杜亚泉等人在 1916 年前后已经提出其中的主要问题.东西文化有何差异、孰优孰劣、能否调和、如何调和等议题的展开,呈现了共和制新生时期的中国思想界探寻现代中国新的文明基础的重要一步,也是现代中国知识思想转型的重要一步.
Exploring the Civilization Foundation of Modern China:Kang Youwei's Civilization Discourse and Beginning of Debate on Culture Issues Between the East and the West
Kang Youwei,in the early 20th century,developed a discourse on the superiority of Chinese civilization and Western civilization by distinguishing between the material and moral aspects of civilization,sparking a debate on cultural issues between the East and the West.The European civilization crisis presented by the outbreak of World War I and the republican crisis presen-ted by Yuan Shikai's restoration of the Republic of China have sparked two opposing views.Chen Duxiu's views on the irrecon-cilability of Eastern and Western civilizations and the theory of"complete Westernization",as well as his opposition to Gu Hongming's claim of using Chinese civilization to save European civilization,have formed a confrontational pattern,clearly demonstrating the foundation of modern Chinese civilization construction,which is very different from the debate on Yi-Xia differences in the dynastic era.More scholars advocate the theory of harmony between Eastern and Western civilizations,and Li Dazhao,Du Yaquan,and others have already raised the main issues around 1916.The development of issues such as the differ-ences between Eastern and Western cultures,which one is stronger or weaker,whether they can be reconciled,and how they can be reconciled,presents an important step for the Chinese intellectual community in the new era of republicanism to explore the new foundation of modern Chinese civilization,and is also an important step in the transformation of modern Chinese knowl-edge and ideology.

civilization foundation of modern Chinadebate on Yi-Xia differencesdebate on culture issues between the East and the WestKang Youwei

张翔

展开 >

中央民族大学 文学院,北京 100081

现代中国的文明基础 夷夏之辨 东西文化论战 康有为

2024

杭州师范大学学报(社会科学版)
杭州师范大学

杭州师范大学学报(社会科学版)

CHSSCD
影响因子:0.429
ISSN:1674-2338
年,卷(期):2024.46(2)
  • 34