首页|内涵及法益重塑视角下再论网络谣言的刑法治理

内涵及法益重塑视角下再论网络谣言的刑法治理

扫码查看
我国《刑法》对网络谣言的治理主要体现于编造、故意传播虚假信息罪等专门罪名的适用,这些罪名中"虚假信息"这一法条用语在罪刑法定原则的视角下与网络谣言同义,但网络谣言的内涵有未经证实性说和虚假性说之分,前者有内在缺陷并将引发诸多法治和社会问题而应被摒弃,应采用后者解释"虚假信息"这一法条用语并以此重塑网络谣言的内涵,但在司法实践中需要采取配套措施予以保障.作为替代措施,公安机关可在谨慎、保守的前提下根据我国《治安管理处罚法》将未经证实的信息认定为网络谣言而对行为人进行治安处罚.可根据虚假性说将编造、故意传播虚假信息罪的法益重塑为公众对特定公共事件的真相知情权,将编造、故意传播虚假恐怖信息罪的法益重塑为公众对恐怖事件的真相知情权和精神安宁权.以此方式可进一步在网络谣言领域实现刑法治理的法治化和合理化.
The Criminal Law Governance of Online Rumour from the Perspective of Connotation and Legal Interest Reconstruction
The governance of online rumor in Criminal Law of the People's Republic of China is mainly reflected in the applica-tion of specialized charges such as the crime of fabricating and intentionally spreading false information.In these charges,the le-gal term"false information"is synonymous with online rumor from the perspective of the principle of legality.However,the connotation of online rumor includes the theory of unsubstantiated nature and the theory of falsehood.The former should be aban-doned because it has inherent defects and will cause many legal and social problems.The latter should be used to interpret the le-gal term"false information"and thereby reshaping the connotation of online rumor,but supporting measures needs to be taken to protect it in judicial practice.As an alternative measure,the public security organ can identify unverified information as online rumor and impose a public security penalty on the conductor in accordance with Law of the PRC on Public Security Administra-tionunder the premise of prudence and conservatism.According to the theory of falsehood,the legal interest of the crime of fab-ricating and intentionally spreading false information can be reshaped as the public's right of knowing the truth of specific public events,and the legal interest of the crime of fabricating and intentionally spreading false terrorist information can be reshaped as the public's right of knowing the truth of terrorist events and the right of spiritual tranquility.In this way,the rule of law and the rationalization of criminal governance can be further realized in the field of online rumors.

online rumourinformationdataInternetspreadthe criminal law governance

王德政

展开 >

西南石油大学 法学院,四川 成都 610500

网络谣言 信息 数据 互联网 传播 刑法治理

司法部法治建设与法学理论研究部级科研项目

21SFB4036

2024

杭州师范大学学报(社会科学版)
杭州师范大学

杭州师范大学学报(社会科学版)

CHSSCD
影响因子:0.429
ISSN:1674-2338
年,卷(期):2024.46(2)
  • 69