首页|内容带货对免费知识分享行为的溢出效应

内容带货对免费知识分享行为的溢出效应

扫码查看
知识分享平台推出内容带货形式,试图打造免费与付费相融合的全新知识分享场景.免费知识分享是知识分享平台持续发展的根基,而内容带货的出现是否对原有免费知识分享行为产生非预期影响值得探究.虽然已有研究探究了知乎Live和付费咨询型经济激励策略对免费知识分享行为的非预期影响,但内容带货作为知识分享平台中的新型经济激励策略,如何影响知识生产者的免费知识分享行为尚未可知.利用知乎推出好物推荐策略的准自然实验,基于动机拥挤理论,探究内容带货对知识生产者免费知识分享的数量和努力程度的溢出效应,以及考察内容带货对不同声誉的知识生产者的异质性影响.采用文本分析法对回答内容进行细粒度挖掘,将回答内容的文本长度、主题多样性、回答与问题文本的相关性以及三者的均值作为免费知识分享努力程度的测量指标.采用倾向得分匹配和双重差分法检验研究模型和假设.采用实际经济激励效应检验、平行趋势检验、避免极端值的影响、更换倾向得分匹配方法和安慰剂检验验证结果的稳健性.研究结果表明,内容带货对知识生产者免费知识分享的数量和努力程度产生正向溢出效应,表现为回答数量增加、回答文本更长、回答主题更多样以及回答与问题文本的相关性更强;内容带货对低声誉知识生产者免费知识分享的数量和努力程度产生的正向溢出效应比高声誉知识生产者更强,稳健性检验结果表明该结论成立.研究结果为知识分享平台采用内容带货策略提供了理论依据,避免了平台管理者低估内容带货为平台运营带来的总体效益;同时,有助于平台管理者针对异质性知识生产者实施差异化管理策略,进一步发挥内容带货的积极溢出作用.因此,研究结果对于知识分享平台完善商业化转型模式,打造免费与付费和谐共存的知识分享生态具有重要决策参考价值.
The Spillover Effect of Content Marketing on Free Knowledge Sharing Behavior
The knowledge sharing platform has launched content marketing,in an attempt to create a new knowledge sharing scenario that combines free and paid services.Free knowledge sharing is the foundation of knowledge sharing platforms'sus-tainable development.Therefore,it is worth pondering whether content marketing will unexpectedly affect the original free knowledge sharing behavior.While the existing literature has explored the unexpected effects of the economic incentive strategies of Zhihu Live and paid consultation on free knowledge sharing behavior,it is not yet known how content marketing as a new type of economic incentive strategy in knowledge sharing platforms affects knowledge producers'free knowledge sharing behaviors.This study uses the quasi-natural experiment of Zhihu's launch of the"good things recommendation"strategy,based on motivation crowding theory,to explore the spillover effect of content marketing on the quantity and effort of free knowledge sharing among knowledge producers,and to examine the heterogeneous impact of content marketing on knowledge producers with different reputations.This study uses text analytics to conduct fine-grained mining on the answer content,using answer length,topic diversity,relevance of answers to questions,and the mean of the first three as metrics to measure the effort of free knowledge sharing.Adopting propensity score matching and the difference-in-difference methods to test the research model and hypothesis.Finally,the robustness of the results is verified by real economic incentive effect tests,parallel trend tests,avoidance of extremes,replacement of the propensity score matching method,and placebo tests.The results show that content marketing has a positive spillover effect on the quantity and effort of free knowledge shar-ing among knowledge producers,as evidenced by an increase in the number of answers,longer answer texts,more diverse an-swer topics,and greater relevance of answers to questions;Compared to knowledge producers with a high reputation,content marketing has a more substantial positive spillover effect on the quantity and effort of free knowledge sharing among know-ledge producers with a low reputation.The findings still hold after a series of robustness tests.The results provide a theoretical basis for knowledge sharing platforms to adopt content marketing,preventing platform managers from underestimating the overall benefits of content marketing.The results also help platform managers implement differentiated management strategies for heterogeneous knowledge producers,further exploiting the positive spillover effects of content marketing.Therefore,the research results have important decision-making reference value for knowledge sharing platforms improving the commercialization transformation model and creating a harmonious coexistence of free and paid knowledge sharing ecology.

content marketinggood things recommendationfree knowledge sharingmotivation crowding theoryspillover ef-fect

齐托托、王天梅

展开 >

首都经济贸易大学工商管理学院,北京 100071

中央财经大学信息学院,北京 100081

内容带货 好物推荐 免费知识分享 动机拥挤理论 溢出效应

国家自然科学基金国家自然科学基金首都经济贸易大学新入职青年教师科研启动基金

7207219472402146XRZ2024011

2024

管理科学
哈尔滨工业大学管理学院

管理科学

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:2.688
ISSN:1672-0334
年,卷(期):2024.37(1)