首页|差别原则、平等主义与优先主义

差别原则、平等主义与优先主义

扫码查看
差别原则是罗尔斯正义理论的重要组成部分.不少学者从优先主义的视角阐释差别原则,认为差别原则在将绝对优先性给予处境最差者时,未顾及处境较好者可能遭受的较大损失,从而导致"向下拉平"现象的出现.实际上,该问题主要源自对差别原则的优先主义的不当解读,并不是差别原则本身的问题.差别原则与优先主义之间存在差异,前者在界定处境最差者时主要采取一种比较性的标准,后者则关注人的绝对水平.人们不应该对差别原则进行优先主义的解读,应当将差别原则视为一种义务论平等主义.
The Difference Principle,Egalitarianism and Prioritarianism
The difference principle is an integral part of Rawls's theory of justice.Many scholars explain it from the perspective of prioritarianism and state that when giving absolute priority to those in the worst situation,the difference principle does not consider the greater losses that those in better situations may suffer,resulting in leveling down.This problem mainly stems from its improper interpretation,not the issue of the difference prin-ciple itself.There is a difference between the difference principle and prioritarianism.The difference principle mainly adopts a comparative standard when defining the person in the worst situation,which differs from priori-tarianism concerning the absolute level of human beings.People should not interpret the difference principle in terms of prioritarianism but regard it as a deontic egalitarianism.

高景柱

展开 >

天津师范大学政治与行政学院

平等主义 优先主义 差别原则 罗尔斯

国家社会科学基金重大项目

21&ZD160

2024

江海学刊
江苏省社会科学院

江海学刊

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.873
ISSN:1000-856X
年,卷(期):2024.(3)