首页|马克思大学时期与浪漫主义的邂逅及其诀别

马克思大学时期与浪漫主义的邂逅及其诀别

Marx's Encounter and Farewell to Romanticism During His University Years

扫码查看
马克思对浪漫派的自觉批判不是始自《莱茵报》时期,大学时期马克思与浪漫主义的邂逅,同时即意味着某种理论姿态与立场的区别及其诀别.马克思走上学术道路时,浪漫派已近尾声.从学术层面上讲,大学时期马克思对浪漫主义的自觉批判,在他从法学学习向哲学研究的转变过程中已经呈现出来.浪漫派表现为浪漫情绪但又不等于一般的浪漫情绪,大学时期马克思的浪漫情绪、对浪漫派资源的关注以及对积极的浪漫主义一定程度的肯定,都不能说明马克思就是浪漫主义者.大学时期马克思的理想主义是受法国启蒙思想而非德国浪漫派影响的结果,实际上,海涅对于浪漫派的批判,从大学时期即影响着马克思.正是有意告别浪漫派之个人风格以及追求更深奥的思想,马克思才转向黑格尔哲学.在柏林大学时期即已展开对历史法学派的批判,是马克思批判浪漫派的典型表现.马克思博士论文的隐秘主题即浪漫派批判,马克思通过伊壁鸠鲁这位古希腊启蒙思想家批判浪漫派的怀疑论及其神秘主义.某种将青年马克思关联于浪漫派的思想,的确意在复兴斯宾诺莎的活力论,这也是当时激进理论界试图激活浪漫派的某种努力,但严格说来,这是赫斯式的而不是马克思的道路.当赫斯试图回到费希特的旧路(因而也是一种重回浪漫派的旧路)时,马克思选择了告别,即告别浪漫派,并持续通向新唯物主义道路.
Marx's conscious critique of the Romantics did not begin in the Rheinische Zeitung period.During his university years,the encounter between Marx and Romanticism also signified the differences and distinctions in a certain theoretical attitude and position.When Marx entered the academic path,the Romantics was nearing its end.From an ac-ademic perspective,Marx's conscious criticism of romanticism during his university years has been demonstrated in his transition from legal research to philosophical research.The Romantics manifests as romantic emotions,but it does not e-quate to general romantic emotions.During his university years,Marx's romantic emotions,his attention to the re-sources of the Romantics,and a certain degree of affirmation of positive Romanticism did not indicate that Marx was a Romanticist.Marx's idealism in college was the result of the influence of the French Enlightenment rather than the Ger-man Romantics.In fact,Heine's critique of the Romantics influenced Marx since his university years.It was precisely because Marx intended to bid farewell to the personal style of the Romantics and pursue more esoteric ideas that he turned to Hegelian philosophy.During the period of the University of Berlin,criticism of the historical law school was already launched,which is a typical manifestation of Marx's criticism of the Romantics.The hidden theme of Marx's doctoral thesis is the criticism of Romanticism.Marx criticizes the skepticism and mysticism of Romanticism through Epicurus,the ancient Greek enlightenment thinker.The idea of linking young Marx to the Romantic movement was indeed aimed at reviving Spinoza's vitality theory,which was also an effort by the radical theorist at the time to activate the Romantic movement.However,strictly speaking,this was Hessian rather than Marx's path.When Hess attempted to return to the old path of Fichte(and thus a return to the old path of the Romantics),Marx chose to bid farewell,that is,bid farewell to the Romantics,and continue on the path of new materialism.

Marx's university periodRomanticismromantic emotionsenlightenmentradical theoretical tra-dition

邹诗鹏

展开 >

复旦大学哲学学院

复旦大学当代国外马克思主义研究中心(上海200433)

马克思大学时期 浪漫主义 浪漫情绪 启蒙 激进理论传统

国家社科基金铸牢中华民族共同体意识研究专项

23VMZ001

2024

吉林大学社会科学学报
吉林大学

吉林大学社会科学学报

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:1.224
ISSN:0257-2834
年,卷(期):2024.64(1)
  • 19