首页|返本抑或生成:理学关于人性修证理论的两种路向

返本抑或生成:理学关于人性修证理论的两种路向

扫码查看
理学对于人的修证方向之论述可分两种:一种可归纳为"返本",另一种可称作"生成"."返本"路向以"复性"说为代表,不管是朱熹的"性理",还是阳明的"本心",皆提倡人在后天的努力中要恢复其初,与此相关联的比喻意象是宝珠、镜子、原初水、赤子等.王阳明已经把良知和气放在一起讲,但仍然关注最初本原.此路向的问题是:如果最初的性理至善无恶,气则有善有恶,如何保证性与气质的一贯性?王夫之看到了这种学说可能带来的问题,才在性气合说的基础上,强调性日生日成的特色,面向当下和未来;同时给恶的来源问题以合理的安顿.这与朱熹、阳明是十分不同的另一种"生成"路向,却又是从朱熹、阳明的人性论问题中发展出来的.
Returning to the Origin or Generating a New Approach;Two Approaches of Neo-Confucianism on the Cultivation of Human Nature
Generally,there are two approaches of Neo-Confucianism on the cultivation of human na-ture.One is known as"returning to the origin",and the other is referred to as"generating".As for the former,represented by the theory of"returning to the good nature of man",whether it is on human nature and moral rule(termed as Xingli in Neo-Confucianism)put forward by Zhu Xi,or on"the orig-inal heart"(termed as Benxin)emphasized by Wang Yangming,it advocates that people should return to their original nature through later efforts.Associated with this concept are metaphorical images such as a precious gem,a mirror,pristine water,or an innocent child.Wang Yangming has combined conscience with objective existence(termed as Qi)in his discussion,but he still focuses on the original nature.The problem in this approach is,if the original human nature and moral rule(Xingli)is inher-ently good and no evil,and the objective existence(Qi)is both good and evil,how can the consistency between the two be ensured?Recognizing the problems that this theory might bring,and based on the above theory,Wang Fuzhi emphasizes that human nature continues to improve as he grows,facing the present and future.This provides a reasonable settlement for the origin of evil.It marks a significant departure from the theories of Zhu Xi and Wang Yangming,though it is developed precisely from their perspectives on human nature.

theory of human natureNeo-Confucianismgood and evilcontinuous improvement of hu-man naturetheory of returning to the good nature of manZhu XiWang YangmingWang Fuzhi

谷继明

展开 >

同济大学人文学院,上海20092

人性论 理学 善恶 日生日成 复性说 朱熹 王阳明 王夫之

2024

吉首大学学报(社会科学版)
吉首大学

吉首大学学报(社会科学版)

CSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.987
ISSN:1007-4074
年,卷(期):2024.45(6)