首页|普通高校博士生"申请—考核"制的问题审视与对策优化

普通高校博士生"申请—考核"制的问题审视与对策优化

扫码查看
在博士生招生制度改革的背景下,传统招考制的弊端已然显现."申请一考核"制因具有其独特的制度优势,在我国众多高校中得到实施,但对普通高校实行该制度的研究尚显不足.采用文本分析法,选取江西省8所普通高校申请考核制招生政策文本,建立二级观测指标体系对样本进行解析.研究发现:各高校申请考核制存在政策文本内容趋同化,部分申请条件有失教育公平;考核评分标准模糊,疏于考察思想品德和心理素质等方面;监督机制和申诉渠道不健全,缺乏对导师权力的制约等问题.鉴于此,建议增强政策文本内容特色,提升申请条件的公平性和科学性;设立明确的考核评分标准,兼顾科研素养与品德素质的考核;以制度实现权责一致,加强对导师权力的约束;健全监督和申诉机制,确保招生程序公开透明,以进一步推动研究生教育深化改革,切实提高博士生人才的选拔和培养质量.
Review and Optimization Strategies for the"Application-Assessment"System of Doctoral Students in Ordinary Universities
Against the backdrop of reform in the recruitment system for doctoral students,the drawbacks of the traditional examination-based system have become apparent.The"application-assessment"system,with its unique institutional advantages,has been implemented in numerous universities in China and become a hot research topic in academia.However,research on the implementation of this system in ordinary univer-sities is still insufficient.Using text analysis methods,this study selects the enrollment policy texts of the"application-assessment"system from eight ordinary universities in Jiangxi Province,and establishes a second-ary observation index system to analyze the samples.The research reveals that there is a convergence in the content of policy texts,and some application conditions are inconsistent with educational equity;the assess-ment and scoring standards are vague,neglecting the examination of ideological and moral qualities and psy-chological qualities;the supervision mechanisms and appeal channels are not sound,and there is a lack of constraints on the power of supervisors.In light of this,it is recommended to enhance the distinctiveness of policy text content,improve the fairness and scientific nature of application conditions;establish clear assess-ment and scoring standards,taking into account the assessment of scientific literacy and moral character;achieve consistency of rights and responsibilities through institutional devices,and strengthen the constraints on the power of supervisors;improve supervision and appeal mechanisms to ensure that the recruitment pro-cess is open and transparent,so as to further promote the deepening reform of graduate education and effec-tively improve the selection and training quality of doctoral talents.

ordinary universitiesdoctoral studentsapplication-assessment systemenrollment systemtext analysis

陈志忠、叶发保

展开 >

江西师范大学教育学院(江西南昌 330022)

美国加州大学洛杉矶分校和加拿大约克大学

普通高校 博士生 "申请—考核"制 招生制度 文本分析

国家社会科学基金2023年度教育学一般课题江西省2022年度学位与研究生教育教学改革课题江西省教育厅研究生创新基金项目

BIA230193JXYJG-2022-048YC2023-S235

2024

教育学术月刊
江西省教育科学研究所,江西省教育学会

教育学术月刊

CHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.77
ISSN:1674-2311
年,卷(期):2024.(8)