首页|导师指导风格对研究生创新能力的影响:一项元分析检验

导师指导风格对研究生创新能力的影响:一项元分析检验

扫码查看
近年来,导师指导风格对研究生创新能力的影响广为学界关注,亦颇具争议.为回应既有争议,本研究基于48913个独立研究生样本,通过元分析方法对导师指导风格与研究生创新能力之间的关系进行了系统性分析.结果发现:导师指导风格整体上与研究生创新能力具有强相关关系,但不同指导风格对研究生创新能力的影响存在显著差异.其中,支持型导师对研究生创新能力的提升作用最强,家长式导师对研究生创新能力的提升作用最弱.同时,导师指导风格对研究生创新能力的影响因个体、群体、组织而异.在导师个体层面,正高级以下职称导师的指导风格对研究生创新能力影响更大;在研究生个体层面,导师指导风格对男生、25岁以下、人文社科、攻读硕士学位研究生创新能力的影响更大.在群体层面,随着师门规模扩大,导师指导风格对研究生创新能力的提升效用也愈发突出.在组织层面,导师指导风格对普通院校研究生创新能力的影响更大.研究结论对从导师指导风格层面提升研究生创新能力的教育管理实践具有重要启示.
The Impact of Supervisory Styles on Postgraduates'Innovation Ability——A Meta-Analytic Examination
In recent years,the impact of supervisory styles on postgraduates'innovation ability has received widespread academic attention,and the assessments are quite controversial.In response to the existing controversies,this paper conducts a systematic review of the relationship between supervisory styles and postgraduates'innovation ability through a meta-analytic examination based on 48,913 independent postgraduates.The results indicate that supervisory styles in a whole has a strong correlation with postgraduates'innovation ability,but there are significant differences among the impact of different supervisory styles on postgraduates'innovation ability.The impact of supportive supervisory style on postgraduates'innovation ability is strongest,while the impact of paternalistic supervisory style on postgraduates'innovation ability is weakest.What's more,the impact of supervisory styles on postgraduates'innovation ability varies between individuals,groups and organizations.At the individual level of supervisors,the supervisory styles of supervisors with professional titles below senior level has a stronger impact on postgraduates'innovation ability.At the individual level of postgraduates,the impact of supervisory styles on the innovation ability of postgraduates who are males or under 25 years old or majoring in humanities and social sciences or studying for a master degree is stronger.At the group level,as the size of the postgraduates'team expands,the impact of supervisory styles on improving the postgraduates'innovation ability becomes more and more prominent.At the organizational level,the impact of supervisory styles on the innovation ability of postgraduates in ordinary universities is stronger.These findings can provide important practical implications for the educational management practice to improve postgraduates'innovation ability from the perspective of supervisory styles.

supervisory stylespostgraduates'innovation abilitymeta-analysis

崔小雨、李辉、苏涛

展开 >

广东警官学院,广州 510230

中国人民公安大学公安管理学院,北京 100038

广东工业大学管理学院,广州 510520

导师指导风格 研究生创新能力 元分析

国家自然科学基金面上项目国家自然科学基金青年项目广东省哲学社会科学规划项目广东工业大学"青年百人"科研项目(A类)

7237203572002045GD22XGL28220413736

2024

研究生教育研究
中国学位与研究生教育学会 中国科学技术大学

研究生教育研究

CSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:1.149
ISSN:2095-1663
年,卷(期):2024.(5)