首页|共同犯罪案件部分适用认罪认罚:问题、成因与完善——以另案处理为视角

共同犯罪案件部分适用认罪认罚:问题、成因与完善——以另案处理为视角

Partial Application of Guilty Plea in Joint Crime Cases:Issues,Causes,and Improvements from the Perspective of Separate Cases Handling

扫码查看
我国刑事另案处理制度产生于服务办案需求之目的,具有公权力主导、阶段适用性与案件特殊性等特点.以共犯是否认罪认罚为标准作另案处理,虽利于提高诉讼效率、提升制度活力,但亦有法律依据不明、制约监督不足、被追诉人权利受限乃至未审先判之虞.究其成因,与我国"重实体、轻程序"的办案传统、动态平衡诉讼观尚未实现、"配合有余、制约不足"的公检法关系以及"案卷笔录中心主义"的裁判方式均有关联.对异化的实践样态纠偏,须在制定统一的另案处理制度体系基础上,从明晰规范标准、加强制约监督效力、落实权利保障以及明确既判力范围等方面完善,以期落实以审判为中心的诉讼体制改革目标.
The separate case handling system in China's criminal justice is designed to meet the needs of case handling,characterized by the dominance of public authority,stage-specific applicability,and case spe-cificity.Handling separate cases based on whether co-offenders plead guilty or not guilty helps improve litiga-tion efficiency and invigorate the system.However,it also faces such problems as unclear legal basis,insuffi-cient supervision,restricted rights of the accused,and the risk of prejudgment.The causes of these issues are linked to China's traditional ways of case handling that prioritizes substance over procedure,the unachieved dy-namic balance in the view of litigation,the cooperative yet insufficiently restrictive relationship between public security,procuratorates,and courts,and the adjudication mode focused on written records.To correct the dis-torted practices,it is essential to establish a unified system for separate case handling,clarify and standardize procedures,strengthen supervision and effectiveness of constraints,ensure the protection of rights,and define the scope of res judicata.These measures aim to implement the trial-centered litigation system reform goals.

separate case handling systemjoint crimeleniency for guilty pleasright to a fair trialrights protection

刘昱彤

展开 >

中国政法大学 刑事司法学院,北京 100088

另案处理制度 共同犯罪 认罪认罚从宽 公正审判权 权利保障

2024

昆明理工大学学报(社会科学版)
昆明理工大学

昆明理工大学学报(社会科学版)

CHSSCD
影响因子:0.676
ISSN:1671-1254
年,卷(期):2024.24(5)