科学技术哲学研究2024,Vol.41Issue(6) :22-28.

视角表征:不一致模型问题的视角主义回应

Perspectival Representation:The Perspectivist Approach to the Problem of Inconsistent Models

胡瑞斌
科学技术哲学研究2024,Vol.41Issue(6) :22-28.

视角表征:不一致模型问题的视角主义回应

Perspectival Representation:The Perspectivist Approach to the Problem of Inconsistent Models

胡瑞斌1
扫码查看

作者信息

  • 1. 南开大学哲学院,天津 300350
  • 折叠

摘要

不一致模型问题产生于不同模型对于相同目标系统的不一致或不兼容表征.科学视角主义的支持者认为,将模型表征视为视角性的,即可消解此问题.然而,这一策略面临实际案例的反驳,而且将重心置于实在论辩护,未能充分回应不一致模型引发的认识论或方法论挑战.视角主义于此仍有可发挥的空间,追踪视角、视角统一和跨视角分析均构成了应对该挑战的可能方法论策略.

Abstract

The problem of inconsistent models arises from inconsistent or incompatible representations of the same target system by different models.Proponents of scientific perspectivism argue that the problem can be dissolved by treating modelling and representations as perspectival.However,this strategy has been refuted by actual cases,and due to the focus on the defense of realism,it has failed to adequately respond to the epistemological or methodologi-cal challenges raised by inconsistent models.Perspectivism continues to play a crucial role,with methodologies such as tracking perspectives,unifying perspectives,and cross-perspective analysis being possible strategies to address this challenge.

关键词

模型/表征/不一致/视角主义/方法论

Key words

model/representation/inconsistency/perspectivism/methodology

引用本文复制引用

出版年

2024
科学技术哲学研究
山西大学 山西省自然辩证法研究会

科学技术哲学研究

CSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.299
ISSN:1674-7062
段落导航相关论文