临床误诊误治2024,Vol.37Issue(5) :73-78.DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1002-3429.2024.05.014

种植牙手术前后CBCT参数预测种植体早期稳定性的效能分析

Efficacy Analysis of CBCT Parameters in Predicting the Early Stability of Implants before and after Dental Implant Surgery

蒋冰坤 宁慧影
临床误诊误治2024,Vol.37Issue(5) :73-78.DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1002-3429.2024.05.014

种植牙手术前后CBCT参数预测种植体早期稳定性的效能分析

Efficacy Analysis of CBCT Parameters in Predicting the Early Stability of Implants before and after Dental Implant Surgery

蒋冰坤 1宁慧影2
扫码查看

作者信息

  • 1. 201613 上海,上海市松江区中心医院口腔科
  • 2. 201613 上海,上海市口腔医院牙周科
  • 折叠

摘要

目的 探讨种植牙手术前后锥形束计算机体层摄影术(CBCT)参数预测种植体早期稳定性的效能.方法 选取2020 年6 月—2022 年6 月收治的单颗牙缺损126 例,均拟行种植牙手术,术前采用CBCT测量缺损区域骨密度、骨皮质厚度,术后即刻采用CBCT测量牙槽骨宽度,术后即刻、术后12 周采用Ostell ISQ测量仪测量种植体稳定系数(ISQ值).根据术后12 周ISQ值分为稳定组(ISQ值≥70)102 例与不稳定组(ISQ值<70)24 例.比较2 组基本资料、CBCT参数,术后即刻、术后12 周ISQ值,采用Pearson相关系数分析CBCT参数与ISQ相关性,采用受试者工作特征(ROC)曲线分析CBCT参数对种植体稳定性预测价值.结果 稳定组与不稳定组缺损区域位置、种植体直径差异有统计学意义(P<0.05).不稳定组缺损区域术前骨密度、术前骨皮质厚度及术后即刻、术后 12 周ISQ值低于稳定组(P<0.05).下颌前牙缺损患者缺损区域术前骨密度、术前骨皮质厚度>下颌后牙缺损患者>上颌前牙缺损患者>上颌后牙缺损患者(P<0.05);种植体直径4.8、4.1 mm患者缺损区域术前骨密度、术前骨皮质厚度高于种植体直径3.3 mm患者(P<0.05).下颌后牙缺损患者术后即刻、术后12 周ISQ值下颌后牙缺损患者>下颌前牙缺损患者>上颌后牙缺损患者>上颌前牙缺损患者(P<0.05);种植体直径4.8、4.1 mm患者缺损区域术后即刻、术后12 周ISQ值高于种植体直径3.3 mm患者(P<0.05).缺损区域术前骨密度、术前骨皮质厚度与术后即刻、术后 12 周ISQ值呈正相关(P<0.01),术后即刻牙槽骨宽度与术后即刻、术后 12 周ISQ值无明显相关性(P>0.05).ROC曲线分析,缺损区域术前骨密度、术前骨皮质厚度预测术后 12 周种植体稳定性的曲线下面积分别为 0.711(95%CI:0.624,0.788)、0.759(95%CI:0.674,0.830),敏感度分别为 53.92%、74.51%,特异度分别为 87.75%、70.83%.结论 CBCT测量缺损区域术前骨密度、术前骨皮质厚度与种植体早期稳定性密切相关,预测种植体早期稳定性的效能良好,术后即刻牙槽骨宽度与种植体早期稳定性无明显相关性,无法有效预测种植体早期稳定性.

Abstract

Objective To investigate the efficacy of conical beam computerized tomography(CBCT)parameters in predicting the early stability of implants before and after dental implant surgery.Methods A total of 126 patients with single tooth defect treated from June 2020 to June 2022 were selected,all of which were intended to undergo dental implant surgery.CBCT was used to measure the bone mineral density(BMD)and cortical thickness of the defect area before surgery,and the alveolar bone width was measured by CBCT immediately after surgery.Implant stability quotient(ISQ)value was measured by Ostell ISQ measuring instrument immediately and at 12 weeks after surgery.According to the ISQ value at 12 weeks after sur-gery,they were divided into stable group(ISQ value≥70,n=102)and unstable group(ISQ value<70,n=24).Basic data and CBCT parameters as well as ISQ values immediately after surgery and at 12 weeks after surgery were compared be-tween the two groups.Pearson correlation coefficient was used to analyze the correlation between CBCT parameters and ISQ,and receiver operating characteristics(ROC)curve was used to analyze the predictive value of CBCT parameters for stability.Results The location and implant diameter of the defect area were significantly different between the stable group and the un-stable group(P<0.05).BMD,cortical thickness,ISQ immediately after surgery and at 12 weeks after surgery in the defect area in the unstable group were lower than those in the stable group(P<0.05).Preoperative BMD and bone cortical thick-ness in patients with mandibular anterior tooth defect were the largest,followed by patients with mandibular posterior tooth de-fect patients,patients with maxillary anterior tooth defect and patients with maxillary posterior tooth defect(P<0.05).The preoperative BMD and cortical thickness of defect area in patients with implant diameter of 4.8 and 4.1 mm were higher than those in patients with implant diameter of 3.3 mm(P<0.05).The ISQ value in patients with mandibular posterior teeth was the largest,followed by patients with mandibular anterior teeth defect,patients with maxillary posterior teeth defect and pa-tients with maxillary anterior teeth defect immediately after surgery and at 12 weeks after surgery(P<0.05).The ISQ values immediately after surgery and at 12 weeks after surgery in patients with implant diameter of 4.8 and 4.1 mm were higher than those in patients with implant diameter of 3.3 mm(P<0.05).BMD and cortical thickness of the defect area were positively correlated with ISQ values immediately after surgery and at 12 weeks after surgery(P<0.01),while alveolar bone width im-mediately after surgery was not significantly correlated with ISQ values immediately after surgery and at 12 weeks after surgery(P>0.05).ROC curve analysis showed that the area under the ROC curve(AUC)of BMD and cortical thickness of the de-fected area before surgery to predict stability at 12 weeks after surgery were 0.711(95%CI:0.624,0.788)and 0.759(95%CI:0.674,0.830),sensitivity was53.92%and74.51%respectively,and specificity was87.75%and70.83%re-spectively.Conclusion CBCT measurement of BMD and cortical thickness of the defect area before surgery is closely related to the early stability of the implant,and has good efficacy in predicting the early stability of the implant.Immediately after sur-gery,the alveolar bone width has no significant correlation with the early stability of the implant,and can not effectively pre-dict the early stability of the implant.

关键词

牙缺损/锥形束计算机体层摄影术/牙种植体,单牙/稳定性/骨密度/骨皮质厚度/ROC曲线/曲线下面积

Key words

Tooth defect/Cone-beam computed tomography/Dental implants,single-tooth/Stability/Bone density/Cortical thickness/ROC curve/Area under the curve

引用本文复制引用

基金项目

上海市松江区科技攻关计划(16SJGG41)

出版年

2024
临床误诊误治
解放军白求恩国际和平医院

临床误诊误治

CSTPCD
影响因子:0.914
ISSN:1002-3429
参考文献量27
段落导航相关论文